I brought up free will in the context of conscious computers. There may be some controversy as to whether our minds are subject to the laws of physics, but certainly our computers must be, otherwise they would be useless. I suppose they could be conscious and just do what they are supposed to do, but then of course we could never know that they are conscious, and that would be pretty boring too, because the only reason we are interested in computers becoming conscious is because they might be TAKING OVER. The whole action in a computer is the flow of electrons and if they should suddenly divert from their ordained paths to say, Whazzup Doc, why the laws of physics would be tossed into that handbasket going you know where..
Ticka, ticka? Why yes, now that Beagles brings up the subject I do remember that sound, kind of comforting in the morning against the sound of the coffeepot bubbling up into that little glass knob at the top, and let's throw in the spatter of bacon grease in the frying pan. What a way to greet the day. I'm not good at mechanical stuff, but my guess is when you shove that handle down you are turning a cogged wheel which afterwards tika tikas through every cog until when its circuit is run it frees some lever that pops the bread out of the slot and the aroma of burnt toast commingles with freshly brewed coffee and crisp bacon. How nice.
But what is this, modern toasters don't tika tika anymore? I hadn't noticed. I just now went into the kitchen and shoved down the handle and put my ear down where those deadly filaments glow, and nada. What the fuck? Already I am nostalgic for the good old days of tika tika, oh life was sweet then, anymore it is silent and soulless.
But wait what is this about the toast not coming out the same way every time? What if it came out just fine the first three times, but not the fourth, then okay again on the fifth, but not the sixth, good on the seventh, but not good again until the eleventh time, and henceforth less and less often, good on the thirteenth, the seventeenth, the nineteenth, and twenty third? Do you see the pattern Junior Mathematician? Prime numbers! The very thing we print on our space probes to prove to the aliens that we are intelligent. Your toaster, your new modern tika tika less device, most likely containing some kind of chip was telling you that it was alive.
Well you know, so are mice, but that doesn't mean we want them in our houses does it?
Barton Fink was a great movie, but I don't know what it has to do with OR. Well John Goodman's character is nuts, and there is some kind of murder I think, some woman and some kind of coverup, and there is a William Faulkner character, but no Descartes or Spinoza as I recall.
I never quite got dialectical materialism. I'm all for matter being objective reality but what does that have to do with communism?
Search This Blog
Wednesday, December 14, 2016
Tuesday, December 13, 2016
Determinism vs. Free Will
I seem to remember that Ken and I discussed this some time before Old Dog joined us at the Institute. That's another one of those things that you can't conclusively prove, you either believe in it or you don't. I believe we ended up agreeing that it's a good policy to act as if you believed in free will, even if you don't, otherwise you would never get anything done....or something like that. My opinion on the subject is that life is like a poker game, you can't control which cards you are dealt, but you can decide which ones to keep and which ones to throw away.
I would define a good toaster as one that consistently makes toast the way I like it, and a bad toaster as one that doesn't. My hypothetical wife and I gave up on toasters a long time ago. Ever since they "improved" the old fashioned toasters, the ones that used to go "ticka-ticka", by making them work electronically, we had never been able to get our toast to come out the same way twice. Then we discovered toaster ovens, I think my mother gave us her old one after she got a new one. They don't last forever, and I believe we're on our third one now, but they go "ticka-ticka", and they have a window which enables you to watch the toast and pull it out if it looks done before the timer runs its course. That's the best kind of machine, one that you control yourself, or at least can intervene if the thing decides to disregard your instructions.
Now they are making driverless cars. Why? Who needs them? We both have cruise control on our cars, but neither of us have ever used it. The gas pedal and the brake pedal are all the cruise control we need. I like the idea of an automatic braking system that takes over if you fall asleep at the wheel or something, as long as it works properly. If I had that on my car, though, I would find some way to disable it the first time it gave me any shit. No matter how useful or how smart a machine is, it needs to be kept in its place. Otherwise, the next thing you know, they will be taking over our neighborhoods, marrying our daughters, and getting themselves elected President of the United States. No good can come of that!
I would define a good toaster as one that consistently makes toast the way I like it, and a bad toaster as one that doesn't. My hypothetical wife and I gave up on toasters a long time ago. Ever since they "improved" the old fashioned toasters, the ones that used to go "ticka-ticka", by making them work electronically, we had never been able to get our toast to come out the same way twice. Then we discovered toaster ovens, I think my mother gave us her old one after she got a new one. They don't last forever, and I believe we're on our third one now, but they go "ticka-ticka", and they have a window which enables you to watch the toast and pull it out if it looks done before the timer runs its course. That's the best kind of machine, one that you control yourself, or at least can intervene if the thing decides to disregard your instructions.
Now they are making driverless cars. Why? Who needs them? We both have cruise control on our cars, but neither of us have ever used it. The gas pedal and the brake pedal are all the cruise control we need. I like the idea of an automatic braking system that takes over if you fall asleep at the wheel or something, as long as it works properly. If I had that on my car, though, I would find some way to disable it the first time it gave me any shit. No matter how useful or how smart a machine is, it needs to be kept in its place. Otherwise, the next thing you know, they will be taking over our neighborhoods, marrying our daughters, and getting themselves elected President of the United States. No good can come of that!
Simple choices
"As you know i don't believe in free will for people so why am i going to believe in it for computers."
Is this Uncle Ken's version of click-bait? I don't recall the subject of free will ever being discussed at the seminars but there's a lot I don't recall, so it's possible it was discussed at length and resolved to everyone's satisfaction. And I'll leave it at that.
-----
My foray to understand certain aspects of reality has left me exhausted after encountering the following two items:
Objective vs. Subjective Reality in Barton Fink (title of article)
and
The philosophic solution that Lenin (and Engels) proposed was "dialectical materialism", wherein matter is defined as objective reality, theoretically consistent with (new) developments occurred in the sciences.
The great sage Harry Callahan once stated "A man's GOT to know his limitations," and if there is a connection between Barton Fink and dialectical materialism I know I'm in over my head and it's time to bail out. Besides, who wants to argue with Dirty Harry?
Is this Uncle Ken's version of click-bait? I don't recall the subject of free will ever being discussed at the seminars but there's a lot I don't recall, so it's possible it was discussed at length and resolved to everyone's satisfaction. And I'll leave it at that.
-----
My foray to understand certain aspects of reality has left me exhausted after encountering the following two items:
Objective vs. Subjective Reality in Barton Fink (title of article)
and
The philosophic solution that Lenin (and Engels) proposed was "dialectical materialism", wherein matter is defined as objective reality, theoretically consistent with (new) developments occurred in the sciences.
The great sage Harry Callahan once stated "A man's GOT to know his limitations," and if there is a connection between Barton Fink and dialectical materialism I know I'm in over my head and it's time to bail out. Besides, who wants to argue with Dirty Harry?
the football
If the president (who is commander-in-chief) ordered the use of nuclear weapons, he or she would be taken aside by the "carrier" and the briefcase opened. A command signal, or "watch" alert, would then be issued to the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The president would then review the attack options with the aide and decide on a plan, which could range from a single cruise missile to multiple ICBM launches.[citation needed] These are preset war plans developed under OPLAN 8010 (formerly the Single Integrated Operational Plan). Then, using whatever communications technology the satchel contains, the aide would presumably[citation needed]make contact with the National Military Command Center or, in a retaliatory strike situation, multiple airborne command posts (who likely fly Boeing E-4Bs) and/or nuclear-armed submarines.[citation needed]
Before the order can be processed by the military, the president must be positively identified using a special code issued on a plastic card, nicknamed the "biscuit".[5] The United States has a two-man rule in place, and while only the president can order the release of nuclear weapons, the order must be confirmed by the Secretary of Defense (there is a hierarchy of succession in the event that the president is killed in an attack).[5] Once all the codes have been verified, the military would issue attack orders to the proper units. These orders are given and then re-verified for authenticity. It is argued that the President has almost single authority to initiate a nuclear attack since the Secretary of Defense is required to verify the order, but cannot legally veto it.[6][7][8]
This is something I looked up after reading Old Dog's thrilling narrative about the secret cabal that disposes of the Prez when he fucks up real big league. So when the Chinese or maybe the Iranis or even if there should be a lover's quarrel between Dumbo and Putin, and he's mad as hell and not going to take it anymore, what can prevent him from doing a replay of the closing credits of Dr Strangelove?
I suppose those guys who lug the football around could just say damn, we had it a minute ago, or distract him by telling him something bad Rosy O'Donnell had said about him and then egg him on with his tweets as the thought of Armageddon. slips out of his short fingers and his short attention span. Failing that it is up to this Mad Dog guy, who pundits tell me is not as nuts as his name implies. so maybe there is some hope there. Failing that we are at the duck and cover technology that we learned in the first grade.
Speaking of liars I am reminded of a couple bosses I had when I worked for the state. Both were slick talkers but D was a little slower, because his words were going through the sieve of his mind, everything was slanted towards what could he say that would best advance his agenda. If you asked him if it was raining or not, even in that there was as possibility that one answer would better advance his agenda and that was the one that was chosen. P, the faster talker, was more intuitive, whereas D
had to be aware of how what he said would effect Objective Reality she didn't even take it into consideration, I don't think she believed in OR, I believe she believed deep down that her saying so would make it so.
had to be aware of how what he said would effect Objective Reality she didn't even take it into consideration, I don't think she believed in OR, I believe she believed deep down that her saying so would make it so.
I agree with Beagles that a lot of the people who voted for Dumbo, just thought of him as like their uncle Ed, who was full of shit, but not necessarily a bad guy for all that, Even as they were voting for him they weren't sure he was going to build that wall, and didn't care all that much if he didn't. Ah they all lie, I'm sure you've heard that said about politicians, I've probably said it myself, so what's the diff? They just liked to see him sticking it to the Man, and if the country goes down to hell in a handbasket so what, those fancy pants characters had it coming. Now that the fancy pants characters are being put into Dumbo's cabinet, and even more alarmingly the Russkies are being cozied up to I keep waiting for Joe Sixpack to awake with alarm, but so far nada.
I don't know why you guys keep harping on those conscious computers after I have told you no such thing is likely, but nevertheless say if they did, if they were strictly logical they would have no moral compunctions, We carry our morality in our genes, but of course we are also capable of great evils, so I guess the programmer will determine if they are evil or not, but I don't see how you can ascribe good or bad to a toaster.
As you know i don't believe in free will for people so why am i going to believe in it for computers.;
Monday, December 12, 2016
Dueling Realities
In a manner of speaking, you could say that there are two realities existing side by side. First there's objective reality, which is the only reality that is really real. Then there's your perception of reality which only seems real to you. One could argue that, if it seems real, it's real, but one would be mistaken. What seems real to you might not seem real to another guy but, if both of you are reasonably cognizant, your two perceived realities should both be pretty close to the real reality, and to each other. If they weren't, then neither of you would get along very well in the world, or with each other. You both would just be stumbling around, unaware of real hazards that could injure or kill you.
There has been a lot of talk lately about our president elect's tendency to tell lies, not just lies, but outrageous lies. Then, when someone calls him on it, he just blows them off. I have known people like that in my life, and I always wondered if they even knew the difference between truth and falsehood. They must be reasonably aware of their surroundings in order to live successfully on this planet but, when it comes to talking about it, they don't seem to make a distinction between what's real and what isn't. It's all the same to them. I wonder now, of all the people who voted for Trump, how many of them didn't think of him as a liar, but as a regular guy like themselves and their friends. Since they don't make a distinction between truth and falsehood, they don't see why their president should either. It's no big deal to them.
Then there's those conscious computers that are coming. Will they know the difference between fact and fantasy? The computers we have now won't tell a lie unless they have been programmed to do so, and then they don't think of it as a lie. It's just data, and all data is the same to them. Will a self aware computer be so honest, or will it be capable of deluding others and even itself?
There has been a lot of talk lately about our president elect's tendency to tell lies, not just lies, but outrageous lies. Then, when someone calls him on it, he just blows them off. I have known people like that in my life, and I always wondered if they even knew the difference between truth and falsehood. They must be reasonably aware of their surroundings in order to live successfully on this planet but, when it comes to talking about it, they don't seem to make a distinction between what's real and what isn't. It's all the same to them. I wonder now, of all the people who voted for Trump, how many of them didn't think of him as a liar, but as a regular guy like themselves and their friends. Since they don't make a distinction between truth and falsehood, they don't see why their president should either. It's no big deal to them.
Then there's those conscious computers that are coming. Will they know the difference between fact and fantasy? The computers we have now won't tell a lie unless they have been programmed to do so, and then they don't think of it as a lie. It's just data, and all data is the same to them. Will a self aware computer be so honest, or will it be capable of deluding others and even itself?
Another poor bit of fiction
After the inauguration the two men sat in the tight confines of the heavily armored Cadillac, affectionately known as The Beast.
"Wow, this is a lot smaller on the inside than my limo in New York!"
"No kidding, Mr. President, and a lot more secure. You are now the most heavily protected man on the face of the earth, barring a few drug kingpins. Those fools are paranoid, whereas we are merely practical. And you have one thing that they don't have, dozens of patriotic men and women who are sworn to protect you and are willing to put themselves in harm's way at the risk of their own lives. Don't take them lightly. The Secret Service personnel are very good in what they do and they take the responsibility very seriously. You don't want to waste their time.
"But here's the thing, Mr. President. You may think you are the most powerful person, the leader of the most powerful nation on the planet. And that is almost true.
"Did you ever see those photos of presidents on their inauguration day and their photos on the day they left office, and notice how badly they've aged? Every single one of them; they look like shit. But then you see photos taken a few months later and you've never seen a happier bunch of guys. Big smiles most of the time, and not just because their burdens have been lifted. They are no longer a potential target.
"Although you've been well briefed and prepared for the office, there is one thing I couldn't tell you until you were sworn in and we were able to speak in absolute secrecy.
"During the campaign you often claimed that certain things were rigged, and you were closer to the truth than you realized. There are certain laws and procedures that must remain secret, known only to key officials in Congress and the Supreme Court. The FBI doesn't know of them, nor do the CIA or NSA, but these procedures have been in place since Nixon was drunkenly ranting in the White House. Every president since then, on their last day of office, has extended those procedures through a secret Executive Order, which I signed yesterday.
"Those same Secret Service people, willing to take a bullet for your protection, have one higher responsibility, and that is to protect the nation. There may come a time when it is decided that the nation is at such risk due to your decisions that a choice will be made, and your life will be forfeit. Although they are heavily armed it won't be that messy; something in your food, probably, to mimic a stroke or heart attack. At your age and weight it would be quite believable, and this should give you a better understanding of collateral damage."
"I...How...What..,?" replied the new president, sweating profusely despite the cool interior of The Beast. This is not what he wanted to hear, and certainly not according to his plans. His heart was racing and breathing became difficult.
"Oh, there's one final thing, Mr. President, and I'll tell it to you the same way that my predecessor told me:
"GOTCHA!
"But you can never really be sure, can you?"
"Wow, this is a lot smaller on the inside than my limo in New York!"
"No kidding, Mr. President, and a lot more secure. You are now the most heavily protected man on the face of the earth, barring a few drug kingpins. Those fools are paranoid, whereas we are merely practical. And you have one thing that they don't have, dozens of patriotic men and women who are sworn to protect you and are willing to put themselves in harm's way at the risk of their own lives. Don't take them lightly. The Secret Service personnel are very good in what they do and they take the responsibility very seriously. You don't want to waste their time.
"But here's the thing, Mr. President. You may think you are the most powerful person, the leader of the most powerful nation on the planet. And that is almost true.
"Did you ever see those photos of presidents on their inauguration day and their photos on the day they left office, and notice how badly they've aged? Every single one of them; they look like shit. But then you see photos taken a few months later and you've never seen a happier bunch of guys. Big smiles most of the time, and not just because their burdens have been lifted. They are no longer a potential target.
"Although you've been well briefed and prepared for the office, there is one thing I couldn't tell you until you were sworn in and we were able to speak in absolute secrecy.
"During the campaign you often claimed that certain things were rigged, and you were closer to the truth than you realized. There are certain laws and procedures that must remain secret, known only to key officials in Congress and the Supreme Court. The FBI doesn't know of them, nor do the CIA or NSA, but these procedures have been in place since Nixon was drunkenly ranting in the White House. Every president since then, on their last day of office, has extended those procedures through a secret Executive Order, which I signed yesterday.
"Those same Secret Service people, willing to take a bullet for your protection, have one higher responsibility, and that is to protect the nation. There may come a time when it is decided that the nation is at such risk due to your decisions that a choice will be made, and your life will be forfeit. Although they are heavily armed it won't be that messy; something in your food, probably, to mimic a stroke or heart attack. At your age and weight it would be quite believable, and this should give you a better understanding of collateral damage."
"I...How...What..,?" replied the new president, sweating profusely despite the cool interior of The Beast. This is not what he wanted to hear, and certainly not according to his plans. His heart was racing and breathing became difficult.
"Oh, there's one final thing, Mr. President, and I'll tell it to you the same way that my predecessor told me:
"GOTCHA!
"But you can never really be sure, can you?"
Wrapping up the box
Is it a hard and fast rule that objective reality and subjective reality are mutually exclusive ideas? Objective reality is a dandy concept when you are considering the physical world but I think it falls short when you consider the non-physical world, such as human behavior.and processes. Depending on the context of matters under discussion I think they can both work, to varying degrees of success.
Perception plays a big part; aren't we all at the centers of our own realities determined by those perceptions? This is what makes human beings so so frustrating in their individualism. I don't know if I'm just a simplistic dolt, but it seems to me that perceptions vary wildly among individuals, otherwise we would be in complete agreement in everything and that is not the case. The quest for the Beaglesonian Unified Reality Theory continues.
-----
In the interest of fair play, here is another critical view of my delusional speculation of the future of AI: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/artificial-intelligence-artificial-intelligent/
It's going to happen, even if the article puts the time frame in the "far future." I think it will occur sooner than that and I will wager one dollar (American) it happens within our natural lifetimes.
Maybe it is all science fiction, like the writings of Jules Verne or H.G. Wells, way back when. There were a lot of ideas that were thought impossible at one time but the relentless spirit of the human mind made them real, and I don't see people giving up just because something is "impossible."
A greater threat than a self-aware AI might lie in the field of nanotechnology. One writer, Rudy Rucker I believe, wrote something about nanobots escaping a lab and disassembling everything into a gray goo. Perhaps there are some things we shouldn't be messing with. The Law of Unintended Consequences is always ready to bite us in the ass.
And God bless the tabloid press! I read this morning that there are "indications" of structures lying miles beneath the Antarctic ice. I thought last week's report of a strange object casting a shadow on the moon's surface was the peak of lunacy (see what I did there?) but hidden cities under the ice take the cake. Did I mention there are connections to the Nazis? It might be time for the aliens to come out of hiding and straighten everything out.
-----
Uncle Ken clued me in on that orange box mystery. It only appears on the edit page when you are posting something new. I ignored it, figuring it had something to do with leaving feedback to the blogspot folks. Sure enough, I double-clicked it and that is indeed it's purpose. Unless you have a problem with posting something or have a suggestion it can be ignored. Did you guys try selecting it to see what happens?
If that orange box ever bothered me I have a Firefox extension that can temporarily get rid of it, called "Hack the Web." It allows you to select and delete any web page element you desire, especially handy if you want to save and print a page without any ads or extraneous bits of crap. Other browsers might have something similar.
Perception plays a big part; aren't we all at the centers of our own realities determined by those perceptions? This is what makes human beings so so frustrating in their individualism. I don't know if I'm just a simplistic dolt, but it seems to me that perceptions vary wildly among individuals, otherwise we would be in complete agreement in everything and that is not the case. The quest for the Beaglesonian Unified Reality Theory continues.
-----
In the interest of fair play, here is another critical view of my delusional speculation of the future of AI: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/artificial-intelligence-artificial-intelligent/
It's going to happen, even if the article puts the time frame in the "far future." I think it will occur sooner than that and I will wager one dollar (American) it happens within our natural lifetimes.
Maybe it is all science fiction, like the writings of Jules Verne or H.G. Wells, way back when. There were a lot of ideas that were thought impossible at one time but the relentless spirit of the human mind made them real, and I don't see people giving up just because something is "impossible."
A greater threat than a self-aware AI might lie in the field of nanotechnology. One writer, Rudy Rucker I believe, wrote something about nanobots escaping a lab and disassembling everything into a gray goo. Perhaps there are some things we shouldn't be messing with. The Law of Unintended Consequences is always ready to bite us in the ass.
And God bless the tabloid press! I read this morning that there are "indications" of structures lying miles beneath the Antarctic ice. I thought last week's report of a strange object casting a shadow on the moon's surface was the peak of lunacy (see what I did there?) but hidden cities under the ice take the cake. Did I mention there are connections to the Nazis? It might be time for the aliens to come out of hiding and straighten everything out.
-----
Uncle Ken clued me in on that orange box mystery. It only appears on the edit page when you are posting something new. I ignored it, figuring it had something to do with leaving feedback to the blogspot folks. Sure enough, I double-clicked it and that is indeed it's purpose. Unless you have a problem with posting something or have a suggestion it can be ignored. Did you guys try selecting it to see what happens?
If that orange box ever bothered me I have a Firefox extension that can temporarily get rid of it, called "Hack the Web." It allows you to select and delete any web page element you desire, especially handy if you want to save and print a page without any ads or extraneous bits of crap. Other browsers might have something similar.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)