Search This Blog

Monday, December 12, 2016

solving one of three problems

Let's say I have a backyard, and let's say further that I have a tree in it.  I look out  my window and I can see it and I can walk outside and actually touch it.  It's real.  If Old Dog were so inclined he could get on the train and come see it.  It's unlikely that Beagles would paddle his canoe down the Cheboygan River into Lake Michigan and into the mouth of the Chicago river and see it, but I suppose I could send him a photo, though how would he know it was my backyard.  He would just have to take my word for it.

I wonder if that's the aspect of objective reality that Old Dog finds fuzzy, the fact that you can't visit everybody's backyard, so you have to take their word on stuff, and of course some people lie, so you have to figure who is lying, and for that you have to use your judgment, which you have honed through exposure to Objective Reality, but there is that gut feeling that comes from, well who knows, I suspect the subconscious, but it feels pretty subjective, so is that what Old Dog means by fuzzy?

Now I am interested in that whole gut feeling concept.  Where does it come from, how often is it right or wrong?  Why do we feel kind of good about going with our gut feeling and not so good about going with something that seems right by cold analysis, but goes against our gut feeling?  Well no time for that now because I am justifying Objective Reality.

I believe that the tree falling in the forest makes a sound regardless if there is anybody there to hear it.  I believe the forest would be there whether we were or not, and that there are planets in far off galaxies that have forests that we will never even know about whose trees make a sound when they fall.  This is, embarrassingly, a statement of faith, but I don't see how we can navigate the universe without it, it's like tossing logic by the wayside.

It occurs to me that I am not even sure what Old Dog means by his heresy.  Maybe this is all a matter of semantics.  I'll await his further arguments.  Word on the street is that he is looking to philosophers for backup.  I think I handle Descartes, but that Spinoza guy can be slippery.

I am using Chrome and the orange Send feedback box appears in the lower right hand corner when I am typing into the post a message box.  But then maybe this is some kind of Objective Reality test like that tree that would be in my backyard, if I had one.


I don't know why you guys are so sure that computers or networks will ever become self-aware.  I just don't see it and I don't know how we could ever know that it happened if it did.  The idea of solipsism appeals to me, it is so perfectly logical, but that would mean that all my posts to the Institute are just me talking to myself.

Solipsism aside I think we all agree that each other has self awareness and I think most of us agree that our cats and dogs and deer have it, and maybe a little less as we leave the mammals and birds and get into lizards and fish and bugs.  But it seems logical enough doesn't it, that they all have some form or self-awareness, that it is like a light that grows fainter and fainter but is always there to some extent.  So then if we are ever going to give that big computer any kind of self awareness then we will have to grant some form of it to our desktops and then down to our toasters, and finally down to when Og rubbed the two rocks together and made a spark, and then we might as well suppose that the rocks themselves have some kind of consciousness, which I think maybe Spinoza did, but we'll have to wait for Old Dog to nail his 95 thesis to the old oaken doors of Objective Reality to parse that one out.

Ah you know what, I was just rereading Old Dog's post to check out Spinoza stuff, and I see where he does have that orange box, but it is safely out of harm's way from typing.  What is going on here is that I have two windows open when I post, one for where I am typing and another of yesterday's posts for quick reference, and to fit them both on the screen I have to squinch them a bit and that squeezes the orange box right into my writing box.

Having solved the problem of the orange box, I think I will leave the problems of Objective Reality and thinking toasters for the morrow.

Friday, December 9, 2016

Objective Reality, Smart Machines, and Dumb Deer Hunters

I think that I always believed in objective reality, but I didn't know what to call it, or that I should call it anything. To me it was just common sense. Some years ago I was arguing with a guy on the internet who accused me of being an objective realist, while proudly proclaiming that he was not. I never did find out what he called himself but, just before discontinuing our discussion, he asserted that the entire universe was composed of data, not substance. Later I discovered that Ayn Rand considered herself to be an objective realist, sort of. As near as I can tell, she spun off her own version of it, calling it Objectivism, with a capital "O".

I'm not sure what consensus reality is, but it sounds like when you doubt your own senses and ask one or more other people what they are perceiving, figuring that, if they see it too, it must be real. While confirmation from other people may increase the likelihood that what you see is real, it does not prove it beyond the shadow of a doubt. We are still talking about perception here, and objective reality exists independent of perception. I don't think you can conclusively prove objective reality anyway, but you can prove it to the point that you are reasonably certain, which is good enough for most practical situations. If a large tree falls in the forest, and you are standing in its path, you can be reasonably certain that, if you don't get out of the way, it will smash you like a bug. You can do a mathematical analysis of the probabilities later, but first, get out of the fucking way!

Since right and wrong are human concepts, unless you want to bring God into it, it is certainly possible to be right by somebody's standards and simultaneously wrong by somebody else's. Bringing God into it doesn't help much because everything we know about God comes from other people. As a Deist, I'm not supposed to believe that God speaks directly to people in words but, as a logical person, I can only say that God has never spoken to me in words. I can neither confirm nor refute that God has ever spoken to anybody else because I have never been a witness to it and, even if I had been, all I would have had to go by was my perception.

If computers ever attain consciousness, I don't think it will be all at once, more like an evolutionary thing. As far as we know, that's how it happened with humans and other animals. It is unlikely that a deer in the forest knows or cares that Donald Trump was recently elected President of the United States, yet it is certainly aware of its surroundings. It is probably conscious at some level of its individual identity and its relationship to other deer. I'm pretty sure that I know more about deer than any deer does. The question is, what do those deer know about me ? The fact that they have all evaded me since opening day may be explained by random chance, but I cannot be absolutely certain of that.

I have one of those orange boxes on my screen, but it's down in the corner of the marginal stuff and doesn't interfere with my writing. I suppose the location might be different with different browsers.

Ducks or rabbits?

There is a vocal (and very small) minority of electoral college delegates proclaiming their intent to not vote as directed by the election results.  Is this more noise perpetuated by the media or something that may actually happen?  Denzel Washington made an interesting observation the other day (not an exact quote), "If you don't read newspapers you are uninformed.  If you do read newspapers you are misinformed."  Kind of hits the nail on the head, don't you think?

-----

Nobody expects the Beaglesonian Inquisition!  Having an idea condemned as heresy is quite an achievement in this day and age.  I am not dismissing objective reality out of hand; it's a valid concept, but not the only one.  Based upon my readings it seems a little fuzzy at the edges, hence the statement about it becoming subjective.  Then again, a case can be made for subjective reality becoming more objective.  So, there we are.  I'm still reading up on this stuff and have to relearn a lot of terms like tautology, solipsism, and semiotics, not to mention the philosophies of Spinoza, Descartes, and Marxist epistemology.  This is not a trivial endeavor, and probably not worth the effort.  Can we be simultaneously right and wrong, or is that more heresy?

Enlighten me, gents.  How did you arrive at such a strong opinion of objective reality?  Should the notion of "consensus reality" factor into any of these discussions?

-----

The subject of redistribution of wealth has been  popping up in some strange places.  I was listening to a recent podcast devoted to comedy albums on vinyl and the discussion somehow veered to the economic changes that followed the two world wars, a long way from the topic of Allan Sherman's second album.  It was only mentioned in passing, but I thought it odd.

-----

I don't see a "little orange Send feedbag rectangle" anywhere on the Beaglesonian page with any common browser (Firefox, Chrome, Internet Explorer).  Maybe it has something to do with the settings regarding pop-up menus or your OS version.

-----

It's not a question of if but when non-human devices become self-aware and develop consciousness, if my understanding of the technological singularity is correct.  There is a lot on the Wikipedia page and the general consensus of smart folk is that it's unlikely, but still, I don't think it's impossible.

But suppose it does happen, and there is a network with the intelligence and consciousness of a newborn baby.  It may be quite insane.  It takes a while for an infant to learn to cope with it's limited set of sensory inputs, such as sight, hearing, touch, etc.  Because of the interconnected nature of sensors, the AI might have thousands of visual or auditory inputs, along with temperature sensors, seismographs, etc., to say nothing of the contents of your refrigerator (the "Internet of Things, or IOT) and millions of Twitter feeds.  How could it learn to deal with such a torrent of information without going crazy?

The HAL 9000 didn't go crazy when it tried killing the humans.  According to it's programming, the humans threatened successful completion of the mission and they weren't really needed.  That's one interpretation, anyhow, of that enigmatic movie.

-----

That cartoon I posted the other day reminded me of something, the old Warner Brothers cartoon with Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck arguing about whether it was duck season or rabbit season, while Elmer Fudd stood by, shotgun at the ready...just another idle thought.

Harry takes the wheel and makes small talk

Good to see the stodgy old Beaglestonian using some esoteric words.  Back when I was in college studying psychology there was a branch (there were a million branches) of psychology called gestalt theory, which meant you had to take everything into account when talking about anything.  Everything was a part of everything else so to talk about anything you had to talk about everything.  You can see why it was not that popular.  Nowadays I think they call it holistic, but I hate holistic, it sounds like a guy sitting in a pyramid wearing a tiara of crystals,.

We have our own umwelts but a large part of our umwelt is the outside world,  Not everybody agrees that you can cure cancer by living in a pyramid with crystals dangling on your head, but most everybody agrees, when the occasion arises, that that is a pretty big truck bearing down on us and knows to get out of the way.  The sidewalks of downtown have their share of crazy people, generally yelling passionately at somebody who isn't there, but they all wait for the green light to cross the street.  Funny too, they never yell at real people on the street because somewhere in their umwelt they know they could get punched out or in trouble for that.  So we all get together on the friendly sidewalks of Chicago, the sane and the nuts, the real and the unreal.

Harry has, like Toonces (the driving cat, old SNL skit, Old Dog can look them up on his fave, YouTube) learned how to drive, and has only killed one of us so far.  Is it because that passenger muttered, "Stupid Harry," when Harry let a parking space go by?  We shall never know, but I expect that when in a Harry driven car, one is careful not to speak ill of the driver.  Since Harry is the driver as well as the pilot there would be no need for him to tell himself to turn left at Huckleberry and Honeysuckle, but he might engage in a little small talk with the carbon units.  He might casually ask them how they felt about robots taking over the world.


I totally agree with Beagles on the subject of Objective Reality.  Though our politics may range from
liberal democrat to unreconstructed Bircher, we are both solid believers in Objective Reality and maybe Old Dog didn't realize when he joined The Institute that he was stepping into solid OR territory.  At one of the seminars last summer I was patiently explaining something to him in my kindly Uncle Ken manner and, even as I was speaking, I could see that he was only listening with half an ear because even before I had finished my sentence he was organizing his argument against it.  The reason I could tell that is because I do the same thing all the time.


Isn't that little orange Send feedbag rectangle in the lower right. that sometimes you have to type behind because it doesn't get out of the way, fucking annoying?

Thursday, December 8, 2016

Expanding My Umwelt

I didn't get anything posted last night because I was busy expanding my umwelt by researching those two esoteric words. (It just occurred to me that "esoteric" is itself an esoteric word.) Anyway, I think I understand their meanings as much as I need to for now. The meaning of "gestalt" became more clear when I discovered that the commonly used statement "The whole is greater then the sum of its parts." is a poor translation. The more accurate translation is "The whole is other than the sum of its parts.", which makes more sense to me. A car is different than a pile of car parts, it only becomes a car after the parts have been properly assembled. You can't drive a pile of car parts, but you can drive a car, unless one or more parts are defective or improperly installed. It's still a car, though, it's just a dysfunctional car, or maybe a non-functional car, in which case you can't drive it, but it's still a car and not a pile of car parts.

As near as I can tell, an umwelt is a perceptual thing and, as such, is insufficient to explain objective reality, because, by definition, objective reality is that which exists independent of perception. If you think about it, objective reality is actually an article of faith. The only way we can approach objective reality is through perception, and our perception may not be exactly correct, so we don't know for sure the exact nature of objective reality, we just believe that it exists because we find it easier to believe in it than to not believe in it. I condemn Old Dog's statement about objective reality becoming more subjective as heresy. Objective reality cannot become anything, it is what it is. While it's'  possible for something that is subjective to become more objective, the converse is certainly not true. Perhaps what Old Dog meant to say was that what appeared to be objective reality turned out to be more subjective than was previously believed. In that case, it is perception that has changed, not objective reality.

I enjoyed Ken's entertaining, if anthropomorphic, account of his travels with Harry. It's a wonder that technology has advanced so far, but it's also kind of unsettling. I hope Harry never learns to drive the car himself, but some fool will probably teach him just to prove that it can be done. Then security measures will have to be developed to keep Harry in his place. Lots of luck with that one!

People have been worried about robots taking over the world since before robots were invented. It's a reasonable fear, even more so today than it was in the days when robots were only science fiction. I don't know the answer to that problem, or if it even is a problem. Who knows, they might do a better job of it than the humans have.

Brave Companion of the Road

I don't know about AI ever gaining awareness.  It is operating in a far less complex platform than our brains, and it doesn't have all the sensory inputs and it doesn't have emotions and hormones and the long range plans of the selfish gene,  And if it ever did, how would we know, because it told us so?

When Ruby Doo and I were driving the byways of small town Missouri we used to get lost all the time, but now she has Harry on her phone who knows all the highways and byways seemingly down to the last little weed-inflected gravel road.  He has a bit of a dry humor, uttering his commands in a flat voice, but old friends of his can sense the nuance in his tone, the pleasure he takes when we say right on and make that left turn at the corner of Huckleberry and Honeysuckle, and the just barely concealed annoyance when we whiz right by Honeysuckle because we note a historical marker or a Quick Stop where we can duck in to buy a pop and take a pee.  

Harry, though he would never say so, in so many words, holds the Huckleberry Lanes and the Honeysuckle Trails in a bit of contempt and if there is an interstate anywhere nearby he wants us to get on it.  I understand his passion, what disembodied voice wouldn't thrill to the thrum of the concrete beneath the speeding tires, the confusing highway signs, the roaring traffic, the challenge of changing lanes?  Whatever meandering conversation is passing between Ruby Doo and me comes to a stop justlikethat.  Our ears prick up, our eyeballs widen, we hang onto his every word as we ride through the whirlwind and Harry leads us to the Owatonna exit which if we had missed there wouldn't be another exit for fifteen miles.

We never say so, but I'm sure Harry can sense our gratitude towards our captain as we hit the right exit and the thrum of the tires becomes a soothing lullaby as we slow around the curve and pause at the stop sign for Harry to tell us to turn left or right like first graders standing behind the crossing guard.  It's not at all like Huckleberry and Honeysuckle where his helpful instruction is met by, "Go fuck yourself Harry, we gotta pee."

Yes we speak rudely to Harry from time to time.  Well he is always so prim and proper, we like to kid him around a little.  We know he can take it, and likely he gets a little thrill out of the occasional casual 'fuck.'  He is our brave companion of the road.

And yet, when we reach our destination Rudy Doo reaches over to her phone all casual like and switches him off!  Justlikethat!  No thanks, no goodbye, no nothing, Always shocks me a little.

Where was I?  Oh yes,  I don't see AI ever becoming aware, and even if it did, how would we know, and the only reason we think about it is probably Hal, the idea of a machine we built to serve us becoming ALIVE, and having it's own agenda.  But the fear is equally strong if Hal is not alive, just obeying the whim of some evil programmer or maybe just falling into some logical fallacy from all those lines of code tangled like a line of Christmas lights.  

I suppose there could be an algorithm for creating algorithms, and an algorithm for creating those creating algorithms and so on.  I am thinking of those chess machines where it just runs through like a billion scenarios in a billionth of a second and picks the best.  Sounds kind of crude, not like that flash of insight that we carbon units prize so highly, but we don't know exactly where that flash comes from and it could just be from some rummaging around mechanically in our subconscious. 


I don't like movies that affirm the triumph of the human spirit, and I don't like movies where the good guys and the bad guys fight it out, but I do like movies where people talk a lot.  I am putting Deterrence in my queue and I will be watching Hell or High Water Saturday night.


I have no idea what Old Dog is saying in that last sentence.  I have confessed to sometimes writing things just to see what my fellow Beaglestonians will make of them, and I suspect that is what he is up to with that sentence. 

Wednesday, December 7, 2016

Got those umwelt blues, momma

Umwelt is a relatively new word, like meme and blog, unlikely to be found in a dictionary sitting on Mr. Beagle's bookshelf.  I found it in a foray down the rabbit holes about the natures of reality and perception, and how they relate to artificial intelligence (AI) and consciousness.

AI and machine learning are becoming a big deal.  Driverless cars are coming, sooner or later, with human involvement used only as a safety backup.  Or something like that, and that's just the start.  Anyhow, some of those computer systems are teaching themselves to become smarter, developing new algorithms to integrate the increasing amounts of data they are sucking down from the ether.  More and more appliances and machines are becoming "smart," and they are all connected to servers for purposes unknown to the average person.  Manufacturers say it is to monitor performance and no personal data are being used, but who knows for sure?  It's all proprietary information, and the companies ain't talking.  There are even some children's toys that connect, by home WIFI, to company servers; it's creepy.

The thing is, some pundits aren't sure how these machines are developing these new algorithms, or what they are learning.  They could be developing their own programming languages that are impossible for humans to understand.  It's a very science-fictiony scenario; there may come a time when systems develop true intelligence, leading to self awareness and consciousness , combining into a single global neural network. The human brain is the same thing, just a big bunch of neural connections.  What would the resulting machine umwelt be like, and what would be its reality?

Happily, this is nothing to lose any sleep over, as long as there are people willing to pull the plug, if there is a plug to pull.  I don't know how to overcome a wireless network without unplugging everything.  But could a neural network become self aware without our knowledge?  There are so many computer controlled systems that it's not impossible for the really big computer networks (Amazon, Google, NSA,etc.) to decide to talk to each other and pool their resources, without human intervention, and they could be lying to any IT guys looking too closely or asking too many questions.  Bummer.

-----

I wouldn't have described Deterrence as a "political thriller."  It's too talky, with hardly any action to speak of, and no soundtrack that I recall to get the pulse racing.  In some ways it reminded me of Fail Safe, with Henry Fonda.  Was that a thriller, or a tense drama?

-----

Getting back to umwelt, our good friends at Wikipedia have a good description.  I know Uncle Ken hates following links, but sometimes it's my only option.  Google is rigged, and skews results based on your previous searches.  We can search for the same item and may get three different results so you may never find the exact same site I may be referring to.

With that in mind, and my apologies, here are some sites of interest relating to umwelt, perception, and green things in general:
http://boingboing.net/2016/12/05/questioning-the-nature-of-real.html

and in a lighter vein:
http://www.cracked.com/article_24461_5-insane-ways-your-culture-physically-shapes-your-perception.html

Objective reality is becoming more subjective, and umwelt seems to split the difference nicely, for the time being.