Search This Blog

Saturday, December 3, 2016

Saturday bonus!

Nighttime US
Okay, gents, this is something that I've noticed on a lot of maps over the years and I can't figure it out.

It's a natural human tendency to see patterns where none really exist but it sure looks like there is some kind of dividing line going on.  I know it's linked to population, but why is there such a dramatic drop off?  It isn't like there is some giant natural barrier; I would think there should be a more gradual transistion.

Printrbot 3D printers
Any ideas?  I threw in that magnetic declination map to add a new level of weirdness; it probably doesn't really mean anything, but...


Trump voters in red


Subway sandwich shops
Magnetic declination

In over my head

Knowing how much Uncle Ken enjoys a good argument, I can't always tell whether or not he is kidding and is spouting outrageous notions just to see the reaction and get the ball rolling, not unlike certain recently elected political officials.  At the risk of sounding like a blithering idiot and possibly incurring his wrath, I don't know what he means when he uses the term "equality."

Does equality exist in the natural world, or is it a human construct, a theoretical ideal?  I'm all for equal opportunity, equal rights, and equal application of the rule of law; these are all ideas invented by human beings to maintain social stability.  But income equality is an idea that defies logic and I don't understand how it could ever be implemented, especially in our capitalist society.  I'd like some clarification in the context of supply and demand.

-----

The Gini Index is interesting.  Although developed over a hundred years ago, I wasn't aware of it until a few years ago.  I don't think it was on anybody's radar to the extent that it was discussed in everyday conversation.  The most recent figures I've seen indicate a range, on a scale of one, from .25 to .65, more or less; see the Wikipedia entry for more details.  But the Gini Index was created by a statistician, and it shows what is and not what should be.

Income disparity in unavoidable, but low income does not equate abject poverty, at least in these United States.  There may even be some people that live reasonably well with a low income, preferring a simpler life and appreciating quality rather than quantity.  This can cause problems with a consumer driven economy which, barring new types of products, requires repeat customers.  I've never owned a washing machine, but I imagine Mr. Beagles has owned more than one.  I think my mother's washing machine pooped out after twenty years or so, does that sound about right?  I'm sure it could have been repaired but I bought her a new one, anyhow.  Same thing with stoves, refrigerators, and other durable goods.  They're made too damn well and last too long; newer models may be more energy efficient and have more features but not everyone feels the need to upgrade when the new, improved, 2017 models come out.

What a dilemma!  Do we make crappier, more frequently replaceable products just to keep the economy humming?  Same thing with clothes, always a highly marketed product during the holiday season.  Unless you are a dedicated follower of fashion do you often buy new clothes or shoes?  For some folks it's a status thing, or it gives them pleasure, so more power to them.  But fashion is a fickle thing and I don't think it's wise to depend on fleeting and unpredictable public tastes for prolonged economic stability.

-----

My weak understanding of the redistribution of wealth is that wealth should be out in the wild, being spent and invested, and not sitting in a vault or stuffed in a mattress.  Am I getting warm?  I read once that the Renaissance was the product of one of history's greatest redistribution of wealth, the Black Plague.  Lots of folks dying, lots of wealth being spread around but I don't think that's a viable solution for today. But we are victims of our own success; many financial woes are tied into the fact that we are living longer.

Consider the impact of pensions on business and government; more and more money is required to keep up with the commitments made to the retired workers and it's really screwing the budgets.  Another thing I read is that the retirement age of 65 was determined by actuaries, back in the day.  It made sense to them because the average lifespan was...65.  They weren't planning on people living much longer, so it made financial sense.  But with many people now living well into their 80s the pensions can't keep up, and the associated higher costs of health care for the older folks strain the system even further.  I can't see any solution to this issue unless the powers that be decide to deny health care past a certain age, which is a scary thought I choose not to entertain.

Japan, with their aging population, may be on the right track.  They are heavily involved with the development of personal robots for care and companionship of the elderly.  Along the same thread, there was a movie a few years ago dealing with the robot assistant of a retired jewel thief, Robot & Frank (2012).  Not a bad flick.

A final film recommendation, somewhat related to economics and banking, is more recent, Hell or High Water, with Jeff Bridges.  Maybe you've seen it.  If not, it deals with a pair of brothers robbing banks to avoid foreclosure of the family ranch.  It is much more than it seems, and I thought the ending was sublime.

Friday, December 2, 2016

Providing For the General Welfare

I don't think there is anything in the U.S. Constitution that specifically empowers the federal government to redistribute wealth. Congress, however, has the constitutional authority to collect taxes, borrow money, coin money, and regulate its value. It also is empowered to "provide for the general welfare of the United States". This is probably why government charity is commonly called "welfare". Questions have been raised over the years about the exact meaning of "general welfare". Some say that it means the welfare of everybody, not just certain people. This would seem to preclude taking money away from me and giving it to you, which would promote your welfare at the expense of mine. Others have interpreted "general welfare" to mean the welfare of the country as  whole. In other words, anything that is good for the country.

Since we now have an economy that is driven by consumption instead of production, it could be argued that anything that gives people more money to spend is good for the country as a whole. If you take money away from some people and give it to other people, you are not increasing the wealth of the country as a whole, unless the average spending power of the citizens is increased. Ken has argued in the past that the one percenters who now have most of the money are not spending it as much as the poor people would if they had it in their hands. I would argue that they are so spending it, just spending it on different things, but then we would have to count investing as spending. When Joe Six-pack buys another six-pack, he is trading his money for something that he considers to be valuable. When Chauncy Gotrocks invests in the stock market, he is trading his money for a share of stock, which he considers to be something of value. When he later sells that share, it will likely be either more of less valuable than it was when he bought it. Whether Chauncy makes or loses money on the deal, he will likely buy another share of stock with the proceeds. Ken maintains that this is not true spending because Chauncy's money keeps going around in circles. Joe Six-pack, on the other hand will ultimately piss his investment away, so his money is literally going down the drain. Now which person is contributing more to the economy, and thus the welfare of the country as a whole?

See, economics doesn't have to be boring. Ken may be right, however, that the people who write about economics deliberately make it boring because they don't want the rest of us to become interested in it and compete with them for a slice of the pie. If so, they are ill advised, because more people entering the stock market can only drive up stock prices. The bigger the pie gets, the more slices can be cut out of it. All the pieces may not be the same size, but a little piece is better than no piece at all.

slicing the pie

I just finished my latest copy of the Atlantic and I didn't find either article.  Once before Old Dog was talking about articles he read in the Atlantic and it wasn't until a couple weeks later that I got that issue so maybe it  goes online before hardcopy which sounds peculiar,but this is a cockamamie world.  The issue I just finished was the December one.

I'm not that crazy about the Atlantic, a little stodgy if you ask me.  I prefer the New Yorker which is more sarcastic, or Harpers which is more out there, but sometimes it seems too intelligent for me.

I've been reading about those money guys for some time and I have always cast a fish eye on the assumption that what they are doing is some kind of lubricating of the economy so that it runs like the fine-tuned Mercedes engines that they all have like a dozen idling in their well appointed marble-floored garages.  I'm pretty sure that they are skimming oceans out of the economy in some kind of complicated manner that my eyes glaze over after a couple paragraphs of their explanation.  They have succeeded in making money, one of the most interesting things on God's green Earth, boring so they can stuff their pockets while we nod drowsily and reach for our coffees.



The thing about the weather is that there are just so many air molecules bumping into each other and each bump influences all the subsequent bumps, that they can only be calculated roughly, and the best thing you can do is make a calculated guess.  I read somewhere that to get accurate forecasts they would need to have a weather sensor for like every cubic foot of air.  There are not near as many people as molecules of air, but people are way more complicated than molecules of air and worse still, they are not as logical.

Another thing about the economy is that it is political.  Democrats want to spend money to create jobs which would be good for the economy.  Republicans want to cut taxes and give business a free hand to create jobs which would be good for the economy.  Generally they want to do what they want to do, and then claim that this will help the economy, and economists, fresh out of economy school see which side their bread is buttered on and join one or the other of the two sides.

Yes, what I want to do is redistribute income, and yes preferably from folks richer than me, but I am well off enough, I could contribute a slice of my pie to help out people poorer than me.  Right now the State of Illinois and worse, the city of Chicago, are drowning in debt, the result of not funding pensions.  It would seem like the reasonable thing to do would be raise taxes to pay that off, but there is no talk of that from our elected officials.  There are cranes all over downtown putting up new skyscapers and we have splendid new parks and my heart swells with joy walking through them, but I worry what is to come of all this when we have no cops to walk beats, and no teachers to beat the three Rs into the kids.  I would gladly pay more taxes if it would pay for the things that would make the city more secure.

Ideally I like the ideal of the zero gini where we are all equal, and I think it is worth aiming for, but I don't think we will ever get there, and probably for reasons of human nature it is not even desirable.  If we had control over it there could be a discussion on where we wanted to set it. Maybe the reps would like .9 and the dems like .25 and then they could haggle between them.

The question I have been asking though is, if the gummint could do something about it, should it?  Is this in the range of things the gummint should be doing?  Probably a stupid question though, if the parties thought this was something the voters wanted they would both propose to do something about it, the dems by spending on social programs and the reps by tax breaks for the rich.

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Weathering the Economy

When Mark Twain said "Everybody talks about the weather but nobody does anything about it." he was being a smart aleck. Of course nobody can change the weather, but we all do something about it every day. When you open a window, adjust your thermostat, or put on a jacket, you are doing something about the weather. What Twain should have said was "You can't change the weather, but you can change your response to the weather." but I suppose that wouldn't have been as funny.

Then there's weather forecasting, which has come a long way since the days of Mark Twain, yet it's still not perfect. One would think it would be perfect because it's all done with computers nowadays, but a computer's output is only as good as it's input. "Garbage in, garbage out." as they say. As I understand it, the computer models require a complete set of data, but nobody has a complete set of data so, what they don't know, they make up. That's why they report several possible tracks that a storm might take. Whoever is putting a particular model together plugs in whatever data they have, and then fills in the blanks with whatever they think the data might be if they had it. Thus, different models will make different predictions, depending on what kind of made up data is supplied to each one.

The economy is like that too. The experts are constantly crunching numbers, but different experts crunch different numbers, and some numbers don't get crunched at all because nobody knows about them. People have been trying to control the economy for a long time, but nobody has been able to do it with reliable consistency. Even if somebody could exercise complete control of the economy, it wouldn't be the likes of you and me. As with the weather, the best we can do is try to anticipate what's going to happen so that we can plan our response to it. Sometimes something happens that nobody predicted, and then we can only respond to it after the fact. Sometimes people don't have the resources to respond effectively, the best they can do is try to roll with the punches. Like the weather, we can't control the economy, but that doesn't mean we can't do anything about it.

I think what Ken wants to do about it is to take money from the rich people and give it to the poor people. Presumably he means rich people who are richer than he is and poor people who are poorer than he is. But what if the lines are drawn so that Ken falls on one side or the other? What if the government or somebody determines that Ken is one of the rich people from whom money should be taken? Would he still be in favor of the program? If, after all the one percenters have been looted, the poor are still poor, it seems likely that the 10 percenters will be looted next, then the 20 percenters, and then the 50 percenters. By the time everybody is equal, everybody will be equally poor. Who are they going to loot after that?

There are several reasons why different families around the world spend different amounts on food. One reason is that they are not all eating the same kinds or amounts of food. Another reason is that those families are not all the same size. Another reason is the variations between national economies. When I was in Germany, food was relatively expensive. We used to joke that, if you are going to a German home for dinner, you should eat in the mess hall before you leave. Alcoholic beverages were relatively cheap, but cigarettes were not. Electronic stuff was cheap too, some of the guys bought stereo equipment piece by piece and sent it home, where they would never find deals like that. I have heard that everything is more expensive in Germany today than it was back then. This might be due to differing rates of inflation, or it might have something to do with all this globalization. When I was in Germany, the rate of exchange was four marks to the dollar, and had been for some time. Now I understand that national currency exchange rates go up and down every day, and that there are people who make tons of money trading dollars, marks, and yen back and forth. I don't know if I approve of that or not, and it doesn't matter because nobody cares what I think about it.

Cheap eats and other things

There must be something in the air.  A few days ago I was wandering through the web and found an article about the reasons we have become consumers (in The Atlantic) and then last night Mr. Beagles was discussing consumerism.  Maybe he read the same article, but I prefer to think that the BeagleBoys have their fingers on the pulse of humanity and are well on the way of  resolving all social issues.

It's not all beer and skittles, though.  A different article from The Atlantic was discussing the "case against reality," which may throw a monkey wrench in the previous musings (re: objective reality) of Uncle Ken.  I know he subscribes to the magazine so I will await his analysis, but it seemed like a lot of gobbledygook to me.

So, what is it with The Atlantic, anyhow?  I don't agree with all of their analyses but I have come to respect them; they are reasonable and well written, and seem to cover a lot of topics that I am interested in.  Have their marketing consultants decided to zero in on the Urban Geezer demographic?

-----

For a long time I was under the impression that food in the United States was cheap and plentiful, but there was something I saw quite a while back that changed my mind.  I did a little digging and found it, a pictorial presentation that shows families around the world, what they eat, and how much they spend.  It's an eye-opener to compare and contrast.  There's a family of twelve in Cairo that spends less than $70 a week on food, while a family of four in Germany spends $500.  Both the families and all the food are shown, but the most amazing to me was the family of twelve in Bhutan that spends a whopping $5.03 a week for all of their food.

This boggles my mind.  If I extrapolate correctly, if a family of twelve can be fed for one week then, as a family of one, I should be able to be fed for twelve weeks.  Okay, some of the family members are little kids and older women who won't eat as much as the adult men, but still, it makes me wonder what the hell is going on.  Is packaging and shipping more costly than the food itself?  You can file this under food inequality and see the images here: http://whgbetc.com/hungry-planet.pdf

-----

Another failed impression I had was that corporate CEOs were the ones making all the big dough.  Wrong again, it's the banking and brokerage industry that hauls in the really big cash.  A few hundred million a year is nothing; there's one guy that made over 3 billion in one year.  What does a hedge fund manager do to earn such an amount?  There must be more to it than sitting at a computer and talking on the phone; the financial system must really be rigged.  This is where I read it, maybe you guys can make more sense of it than I was able to: http://www.emolument.com/career_advice/bank_bonuses_2013

dreaming of gini

I do believe that radio was considered the opiate of the people back in the day, and I have some early memories of sitting in the living room staring at this chest of drawers sized radio and listening to programs, Our Baby Snooks and The Green Lantern come to mind.  There used to be, and surely there are now, with all this internet and cable radio stations going around, stations that aired these old shows.  The Lone Ranger, Beagles' show that showed him right from wrong was prominent among those old radio shows.

I agree with Old Dog they were pretty good, not great but good in the way that tv can sometimes be good.  And I know that tv has come a long way since everybody sat down at 8:30 PM of a Wednesday and watched I Remember Mama, but in general it is pretty crappy (a lot of what goes by the name of progress is just more of the same old shit, just faster and faster), and I just want  something to watch with half an eye while I fiddle with the computer before dropping off to sleep.


It took about fifteen seconds of grueling internet research to reveal that what I am thinking of as income inequality is the gini coefficient.  1 is where one guy has everything and 0 is where everybody has the same amount.  I just went to wiki (where by the way I contributed five bucks yesterday because it is an essential research arm of Beaglestonia) and this gini thing is a lot more complicated than I thought it was, but the essential feature is the statistical distribution of wealth.

 I guess in my perfect world the gini would be zero.  We are all created equal and all that crap.  Of course we would never get there the same as we will never end poverty, or drug addiction, or terrorism, but it's a nice thing to work towards, nicer to see the poor man in a tidy cottage and the rich man in a mansion on the hill, than to see the poor man in a ditch and the rich man in a Disneyland castle.  I don't mind, or more properly, I don't see how anything can be done about, individual discrepancies, just how the whole thing balances out.


We all know that the gini index is inching towards zero, and I think everybody except the one percent (soon to be the tenth of a percent) thinks it is a bad thing.  But is it the government's job to do something about it?  Everybody thinks it is the governments job to do something like fight drug addiction, but nobody thinks it is the government's job to stop Hollywood from making those stoopid romcoms.  It seems to me that libertarians would think it is none of the gummint's business whereas those meddling democrats would think it is.


I guess my main tool to lower the gini would be a sharply graduated income tax.  The kind that those conservative pols used to promote, but have gotten out of the habit, that you could do on a postcard, except theirs was a flat tax, and mine would be a soak the rich tax and all income would be counted  Okay that will never happen, but I thought I'd throw it out there if just for an example.

I don't quite get the reasoning behind the social credit, but it doesn't sound that dissimilar from the earned income credit that we have now.  During my McGovern days there was something called the negative income tax which went something like everything you made above say, 25Gs the gummint would take a cut of, but if you made less than that the gummint would give you enough to raise your income to 25Gs.

Everybody says they want a job but mostly what they mean is they want a salary.  As automation continues to steal jobs, we need to have something to pay people for.  How about for, ahem, blogging?  Tweeting your private parts (Just saw Wiener, great doc)?  Posting cat videos on YouTube?  Maybe the internet, the current opiate, can get us through modern times, much like that previous opiate got us through the dark ages.