Search This Blog

Monday, November 16, 2015

the tower of babel

Seems to me that if you are going build that tower to the truth you seek, you are going to have to use bricks made of fact or else the damn thing is going to topple.  And speaking of towers, how about that fine old bible story of Babel?  Kind of makes a point, well the one it makes over and over, don't fuck with the Lord.  It also tucks in a little explanation about why people speak different languages.  So I'm fine with it.

But I wouldn't accept a citation of the story as an explanation of why we speak different languages, and I don't believe there was ever an actual tower.  I'm sure some crackpot can be dug up who says well there used to be those ziggurats in Mesopotamia, and maybe there is some ancient local myth, and surely some verses can be found in the bible, so maybe there actually was blah blah blah, but for all we know somewhere among the people the story was passed along there were some guy who didn't like bridges which is what the story was originally about and decided to substitute towers.  It seems like such a waste of time to manufacture explanations for improbable stories when with one swoop of Occam's razor the problem is solved for good.

I suspect that that story about wolves never killing anybody in North
America was dreamed up by some pro wolf people, and they do like you gun nuts do, just keep repeating it whether it is true or not. 

The thing about credible citations is, if it is in a newspaper, than it was written by a guy who is kind of a professional, who could lose his job if he lied too much, and it was probably overlooked by an editor, and it gives a location and some details which you could probably go there and check out.  It's still possible that the newspaper was ill informed or maybe just told a whopper for some reason, but it is a lot more reliable than what some guy you never heard of said.

I'm sure the DNA was from cat poop or hair and not a photograph.

Catch 22 is not the kind of book you would ever read to find out what the army was like, it was more about bureaucracy.  We were talking about suspension of belief a few posts ago, and if you like the story well enough you can tolerate some stuff that doesn't seem realistic.

I'm always skeptical of these movies that are promoted like, this is what the war in Vietnam, or life in the ghetto, or winter in Cheboygan is really like.  Things like those are different things to different people and it's stupid to pretend that this is what it is like for everybody.

Lions want to eat and everybody wants to go to heaven, and the colosseum crowd wants a good show.  It's a win-win for everybody.  Reminds me of those famous blues lines:


Ev'rybody wants to go to heaven
But nobody wants to die
Ev'rybody wanna hear the truth
But yet, ev'rybody wants to tell a lie

Saturday, November 14, 2015

"Truth is Stranger Than Fact"

That was a recurring line on the old "He-Haw" TV show, which demonstrates that wisdom can sometimes be found in unlikely places. I think that's the difference between you and I, all you care about is facts, while I am a seeker of truth. Those old myths and legends may be short on facts, but they tell you something about the people who lived in those days. Whether they come from Mesopotamia, Israel, Greece, or Rome, they demonstrate that all those people respected was raw power, with a dose of treachery thrown in for good measure. You don't find anything about love or mercy until Jesus came along. Perhaps He was a ahead of his time, and still is even unto this day.

I'm surprised hat you've never heard the myth that wolves have never killed anybody in North America.  I think I have read that Wiki reference you mentioned. If it's the same one, it got most of its information from newspaper accounts, which sounds like documentation to me. I wonder who gets to decide what constitutes documentation or confirmation of a story. If you or I write something on paper, it seems like that ought to constitute a document. If you and I both witness the same event and tell the same story about it, it seems like that ought to constitute confirmation. I don't think that's how it works though. I think you have to be somebody, like one of the cool kids in school. Either you're one of the cool kids or not and, if you have to ask, then you're certainly not. By the way, how did the experts who confirmed that cougar photo get a DNA sample from a photograph?

I read "Catch 22" back when I was in the army. The book came highly recommended, but I didn't think it was all that great. I found it to be just silly and sarcastic, not at all like the military life I was leading at the time. Call me old fashioned, but I have always believed that even a work of fiction should have a ring of authenticity to it. The old "Mash" TV show was like that, you knew it wasn't true, but you got the impression that something like that could happen in the real world. The only unauthentic thing I remember was the guys' hair. I know that the rules often go by the board in combat situations, but even civilians didn't wear their hair that long in the 1950s.

I am not familiar with the name "Donatists", but I am familiar with the story about how the Romans tried to get the Christians to make token sacrifices to their heathen gods. The Christians weren't the first people to resist the practice. The Jews raised such a fuss about it that the Romans finally gave them a special dispensation so they didn't have to do it anymore. It seems that the first Christians, who were mostly Jews, could have weaseled out of it that way. As for the Gentile converts, well the lions have to eat too, you know.



Friday, November 13, 2015

pledging allegiance

Yes that's the difference for me between the reality of the existence of Moses and Jesus.  Because someone is mentioned in the bible is not proof of existence for me.

I have never heard that there is no documented case of wolves killing a human in North America, and i have to say that didn't sound right to me.  Likely it doesn't happen often, but surely it has happened from time to time.  I googled 'deaths by wolves in North America' and the second article that came up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks_in_North_America lists about twenty and seems to be well documented.

Cougar sightings in the midwest until maybe five years ago, used to be pooh poohed, the photos were fuzzy and upon close investigation some of them turned out to be large dogs.  But since then there have been documented cases.  Seven years ago they shot and killed a cougar about six miles north of me in a city alley, and anymore I think it is acknowledged that they have returned to the midwest.

There is a difference between twenty local yokels, who have often reported that they have seen UFOs and some kind of expert.  In the case you cite the guy was able to test for DNA.  I suppose if the twenty local yokels were also able to test for DNA then they would have been believed.

The Pledge of Allegiance is in full force today in Chicago Public Schools.  In my subbing career I was in maybe fifty different elementary schools and in only one of them did they not pledge allegiance every morning.  It was a bane of my existence because I would be trying to collect lunch money or something and then bang, the intercom would come on and everybody would be snapped to attention to say the Pledge of Allegiance, sometimes that would be followed by the star spangled banner or God Bless America, and then maybe a school song and then maybe a few words of wisdom from the assistant principal, and I'm just standing there wondering when it is going to end. 

There was one time when i was sitting in the office waiting for my assignment and the intercom clicked on with the pledge.  I took a quick look up from my newspaper, some clerks, maybe a janitor on a ladder changing a lightbulb, but no kids.  So I went back to my newspaper, but there was an eerie murmur and when I looked up all the clerks and the janitor on the ladder had their hands on their hearts and were mumbling the words.  I dropped my paper and stood up ramrod straight and joined them.

Did you ever read Catch 22?  It was a big book in the 60s.  It takes place during WW 2, and there is a character in it named Major Major, who becomes a major.  None of the other guys like him.  For some reason they think he is a commie.  To thwart him they create some pledge that everybody has to recite several times a day.  Major Major Major, not being a commie, has no problem with this and says the pledge along with everybody else.  This pisses off his enemies who realize that of course a commie would have no problem reciting anything, so they changed the rules so that Major Major Major was not allowed to say the pledge.

Have you heard of the Donatists?  It isn't in the bible, but it is church history.  As you know the Christians got into trouble with the Romans because they refused to sacrifice to the emperor, or the gods of Rome or whatever.  It wasn't a big deal, not unlike saying a pledge and once you were done with that you could go on and worship whoever you liked.  But you know how they Christians were, they refused to do even this little token and that got them in big trouble with the Romans. 

Well not all of the Christians.  Some of them said what the heck and went along to get along, it was only some little sacrifice for Chrissake.  Later on the Christians took over the Roman empire, and the ones who had been persecuted were pissed that the ones who went along to get along were good standing members of the church and wanted to toss them out.  It was a big deal, there was a lot of fighting, in the end the Donatists lost out.

Thursday, November 12, 2015

Historical Proof

Exactly what do you mean by "historical proof"? I assume you mean that you read it in some other book besides the Bible. I have heard before that there is historical proof that Jesus was a real person, and I assume that means the Romans or somebody had a record of Him. Of course the Romans would deny that Jesus rose from the dead, but they might have acknowledged His crucifixion. The ancient Egyptians don't seem to have a record of Moses, at least none has been discovered yet. Is that what the difference is?

This reminds me of the wolves and cougars. I have read numerous times that there is no documented case of wolves killing a human in North America, although it is generally acknowledged that they have done so in Europe. I find it hard to believe that the North American wolves are any less dangerous than European wolves. So what's the skinny here? A few years ago, a woman somewhere in the East was killed by wolves while out jogging, and it was reported in the newspapers. I read somewhere that this incident didn't count because those were wolf-coyote hybrids. If wolves and coyotes are capable of interbreeding, that makes them one in the same species, according to my high school biology book. I remember another incident, way back when we were kids, where a young child was killed by "wild dogs" in a Chicago suburb. If wild dogs could kill somebody right in town, why haven't wolves ever killed anybody anywhere in North America?

Then there's all those "unconfirmed" cougar sightings. What does it take to confirm a sighting? Not long ago, somebody in Northern Michigan published a trail cam picture of what looked like a cougar. After careful inspection of the photo, our DNR confirmed that it was indeed a cougar, and said that this was he first confirmed cougar sighting in Michigan since the 19th Century. Apparently, if 20 other people report seeing something, it's not confirmed until some official person declares it confirmed.

I got to thinking about the Pledge of Allegiance after I signed off last night. Or course you're right that most people recite it without thinking, because that is what we have been conditioned to do. I was half way through first grade before I discovered that we weren't pledging allegiance to the Republican, Richard Strand. I had the pledge memorized long before I was capable of reading it for myself, much less understanding it. I now think it's a mistake to have kids reciting the pledge every day at school, if they even still do that. It should be reserved for instances when it is really necessary to confirm somebody's allegiance, like when admitting immigrants to the country. I read somewhere that, when immigrants used to go through Ellis Island, that they were required to renounce their allegiance to the king or ruler of the country from whence they came, which is where I got the idea.

It wasn't a couple of days after Rev. Al dropped the MYF bomb that I left for Alaska, more like six months. I was in the MYF before Rev. Al took it over, and it was nothing but a social club at that time. I was the youngest member, and everybody else soon graduated from high school and went on to form a young adults' club, taking their leader with them. Then Rev. Al took the reins and tried to put more of a religious spin on it. Suddenly I wasn't the youngest member, I was the oldest, and the newbies elected me president. It was good for a year or two, and then I did something really stupid involving the opposite sex. It wasn't a sin by your definition because I didn't realize before the fact that it was wrong, although I should have, which is why I said it was really stupid. Be that as it may, if I end up in Hell because of that one incident, I won't even  argue about it. If you want details, I will send them in an email, but I need your solemn word that it won't end up in our blog, or in your movie script either.

no more myf story

I have a little trouble with that suspension of belief thing in movies.  I can get along with science fiction since that premise is right there at the beginning, and sometimes there is some strange event that you accept because it is the reason for the story.  But if there are too many coincidences or if the people act in a way that I don't think people act in the real world, then I don't like the movie.  What I particularly don't like is when there is an obvious good guy and an obvious bad guy, especially when the good guy is all good, and the bad guy is all bad, and especially then because you know exactly what is going to happen.  It is going to end with the good guy punching out the bad guy in the abandoned warehouse.

It's not the mention of God that incurs my disbelief.  I believe that there was a guy named Jesus and that he was crucified and certainly God is all over that story.  And I believe that because there is some historical proof to back it up.  I don't believe any of the Greek myths, and it seems like everybody has some kind of creation myth and I don't believe any of them.  I am a very skeptical person.  That thing where people already believe something and then just pick facts and theories to back up what they believe and toss out everything that would contradict it, I dismiss it out of hand.  Haven't used that phrase in awhile.  Feels good.

You are aware that almost everybody mumbles the pledge of allegiance with no thought of its meaning.  I don't think it's a sad commentary on the modern world, I think it was ever thus.  I certainly didn't pay any attention to it, except to remember to splice in that 'under god,' in the right place, back in the fifties.  The problem with all those pledges and oaths and creeds is that they are mandatory, you have to say them.  I suppose you could refuse to say the pledge, but any grade schooler knows they would get in trouble for that.  I imagine young Beagles might have said something if he had trouble with it.  I am surprised that he did not refuse on the grounds that it was written by a socialist but maybe he didn't know it at the time.

What I do when I have trouble with spelling a word is I google it, and you know by the time you have three or four letters into the little box, google is giving you suggestions and sometimes you can tell from that what the correct spelling is.  For something like suffrage I would type in 'right to vote,' and see what the google tells me. 

I type my posts into a blank email, that way I am using my own spellchecker who I have already told what words I consider correct.  Then I copy and paste it into the blogger box.

I'm not trying to make a point with the MYF story.  I just like to tell stories.  I look at a painting and I see a story in it.  I see a couple walking down the street and stepping into the frozen yogurt shop and I want to tell a story about them.  That whole thing about the Rev Al blowing the door off and you leaving for Alaska (even though I know the two are not related) a couple days later just seemed like such a good story that I wanted to write it just to see where it went. 

I guess it's sarcastic because I am sarcastic, it's just something I gravitate towards.  Sometimes I thought that I might have had a career in advertising except that I would never be able to resist sarcasm.  I didn't mean the story to be sarcastic about you, just sarcastic in general, but if you don't like it I'll stop doing it.

I've always wondered about the MYF.  I guess it was ostensibly for young people to learn more about god, but it seems like the main reason young people went to it was to rub shoulders with the opposite sex, which was probably something the church elders would like so that the kids didn't end up running off with Jews or Catholics or Hare Krishnas.  I'm sure that there were all kinds of kids in it, kids who were there mostly for Jesus and kids who were there mostly to meet the opposite sex, and all degrees in between.  It seems like it would be a good background for the story.

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Oh Ye of Little Faith!

People believe what they want to believe, it's part of human nature. I used to believe a lot of things but, as I grew older, I became more skeptical. That doesn't mean that I don't believe stuff, it just means that I try to keep an open mind. I read somewhere that, in order to enjoy a novel, movie, or TV show, you have to "suspend disbelief". That doesn't mean you swallow it hook, line, and sinker, it just means that you are willing to put your skepticism on hold for the duration of the show. There is no harm in it, as long as you know that, when the show is over, you have to come back to the real world. All this ancient stuff is like that with me. It has no impact on my real life, it's just something that I like to play around with in my spare time. You, on the other hand, refuse to even consider the possibility of any part of a story being true if it has the word "God" in it. All the ancient stories have some reference to God, or a god or goddess, so that means the only things you believe about ancient people is what modern people have written about them. I guess there's nothing wrong with that, if you're not interested in what those ancient people had to say about themselves.

Interesting that you should say that the Pledge of Allegiance is non-binding. Why then do they call it the "Pledge of Allegiance" instead of the "Suggestion of Allegiance"? I can respect somebody who refuses to recite the Pledge of Allegiance because he doesn't believe in it, not so much the guy who stands up and mumbles the words just because everybody else is doing it, and gives no thought to their meaning. I'm sure that the Apostles' Creed and the Nicene Creed were intended to be binding when they were written. The fact that many people today don't consider anything like that to be binding is a sad commentary on modern society, which is why I have renounced it.

Thanks for clearing up that "suffrage" thing for me. That explains why I couldn't find it among the other permutations of the word "suffer". That's the problem with the dictionary, if you don't know how to spell the word it's hard to find it to see how it's spelled. If we had a decent spell checker on Blogger, it would offer suggestions about alternate spellings of a word instead of just telling us that we have it wrong. I guess the squiggly red underlines go away when we post the blog, but I still don't like being told that I'm wrong without being told why I'm wrong.

You have always been good about telling me why you think I'm wrong, so I guess I should tell you why I'm not interested in your MYF fantasy. Truth is, I'm not sure exactly why myself, but I think it has something to do with its sarcastic and frivolous nature. Are you trying to make a point with this thing, or are you just fooling around? Not that there's anything wrong with that!





let Elvis's people go.

I never, ever, ever, ever, said there were no Jews in Egypt.  I have said time and time again that there were surely Jews in Egypt seeking their fortune.  What I have said simply is that I doubt that the Israelis all of a sudden at some point took leave en masse from Egypt pursued by Pharaoh's army.  Makes me wonder if you read what I write.  I wonder if you are even following my serial about The Night the Rev Al Blew off the Doors at the MYF meeting.

I think it's an archaeological fact that Egypt ruled Canaan probably more than once, I believe it is also an archaeological fact that the Sinai was a desert all that time that all of this stuff never happened. 

You appear to be operating on the theory that if somebody has a theory or that if something is written down somewhere, there must be a germ of truth in it.  I believe plenty of those theories and writings have no truth whatsoever in them.  What about the birthers and the truthers and the folks that thing Elvis never left the building?

I don't want to get into this whole god thing again for Christ's sake.  All I am saying is that a lot of those bible stories, especially the old testament and I guess the older they get simply never happened.  If you want to be believe that Elvis was the renegade Pharaoh who crossed the Red Sea during a seiche, I guess it is a free country.

I have heard catholic used in the sense of universal but not very often.  Still, considering that when this was written it surely did refer to the Catholic church since Methodists were about thirteen hundred years down the pike.  I don't know when the particular version we recited at Elsdon was translated into English, but still wasn't the creed something like the pledge of allegiance, that is to say non-binding, and I don't believe it was much trouble when 'under God' was inserted, though I still, when reciting it, take a quick breath after 'one nation,' to remember to insert that phrase.

It's suffrage, not sufferage, if you are refering to voting.

There were only a few MYFers in the basement when Cindy entered.  Beagles was there of course, he was always the first one to arrive at the meeting, it was said that even though the MYFers were all without sin, although one had to wonder about Sally, that Beagles was even more without sin than all the others.  She sat right down next to him, waved her ring and they smiled their secret smile. 

She couldn't put her finger on it, but there was something a little off about Beagle's smile.  Honestly sometimes in his mind he seemed miles away, like about three thousand, Judy reckoned, in a northwesterly direction.