I have to admit that I am a little unsure of the writing of the bible
thing. I think that council just edited the New Testament and not the
old. I had to go to the wiki to make sure of that, and it seems to say
that the Council of Nicea didn't have much to do with the bible so I am
going to leave the matter up to the scholar.
But I do take a little umbrage at the slight on my writing. You know it
was just a sketch, just a proposal. I was still unsure of what exactly
the bombshell was, and in fact I still am. That Revelation convolution
of the resurrection (yes I meant that instead of reconstruction, I've
got to be a little more careful when choosing among spellcheck's
options), just doesn't seem like that big a deal. The good still get
rewarded, the bad punished, God triumphs, what's not to like? Were you
in that big a hurry to meet dear Aunt Rosie? You'd be asleep anyway, so
it would be like right after you died to you.
I'm pretty sure you were going to go to Alaska regardless of the
bombshell, but in the novel that would be what drove Ben, the butcher's
son, to the wilds, while poor Cindy was left behind with his ring on her
finger. And Sally O'Maye, well you know she was doing something.
Have you ever heard of Wise Blood? It's a book/movie by Flannery
O'Connor. It involves a disillusioned Christian who starts his own
church, The Holy Church of Christ Without Christ, where the lame don't
walk, and the blind don't see, and the dead stay that way, Well we were
talking about rewriting the bible and writing in general.
Jews overthrowing their Greek overlords? Must have been Alexander,
actually a Macedonian but I imagine he looked like a Greek to the Jews.
Everybody was vulnerable to the Roman Empire in that day whether they
were squabbling internally or not. And the Jews would have done well
within the Empire if they weren't so churchy and so prudish.
Yes, by morality I mean intuitive altruism and not the rules and regs. I certainly think people make up their own religions because wherever
you find people you find religion. I believe if it wasn't one founding
father it would have been some other guy.
Aha, you made me lose my religion. Well not quite, but the reason my
folks dropped the church was that they wanted all that money to build
the new church, well that and the fact that I was already out of it, and
both my sisters were getting bored with it.
Search This Blog
Thursday, November 5, 2015
Wednesday, November 4, 2015
A Day Late and a Dollar Short
I think it's too late to rewrite the Bible, it's been around too long and some people are pretty attached to it. What you could do is write a sequel, which is kind of what Joseph Smith did. He was the founder of the Mormon Church and was shot to death in his jail cell by an angry mob, but they say an artist must suffer for his work. Then there was Mohamed. Some people swear by him and some people swear at him, but everybody knows his name. I am no expert but, if your Bible writing skills are anything like your movie writing skills, I would advise you to stick to painting.
Some parts of the Bible are more interesting than others. I always preferred the story telling parts to the rants of the prophets and the poetry of King Solomon, but that's just me. One thing you need to keep in mind is that the stories are not always in chronological order. Genesis and Exodus start out that way, but the story line is interrupted by Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, which generally repeats the Exodus story, but with more detail than most people want to know. Joshua picks up where Exodus left off, and then you get into some more stories that are not all in sequential order. Solomon's stuff is right in the middle, then comes the prophets. The New Testament starts out by telling the story of Jesus four times by four different authors, each having a slightly different perspective. The Acts of the Apostles tells about what happened after Jesus left the scene. Then you get into some letters, mostly by Paul, and then its winds up with Revelation, which reads like a surrealistic nightmare. There is another part, called The Apocrypha, which only the Catholics have. I have never read it directly, but I have a book that summarizes it quite well. It's about how the Jews overthrew their Greek overlords and restored the Kingdom of Israel for about one generation, whereupon it fell apart due to internal squabbling like it had done the first time, making it vulnerable to the Roman conquest.
You asked about the "Reconstruction", but I think you meant to say "Resurrection". Like I said before, Jesus and Paul talked about it, but they never explained the whole concept as one would when teaching it to someone who has never heard of it before. I think Revelation was supposed to do that but, you know.....
I don't think that people just make up religions because they have nothing else to do. I was going to say that religions don't just fall from the sky but, many of them claim to have done just that. Some of them likely evolved over time, but many of them have a founding father who may or may not have been a real historical person. Hinduism seems to have been formed by numerous religions assimilating each other, and Christianity itself has done some of that. If, by "morality". you mean intuitive altruism and are excluding all the specific rules and regulations, I tend to agree that probably came first. I am not done with those Canaanites yet, there is more I want to know about them, and will look into it when I get some time.
Yes, it was the trashing of our cherished misconceptions about Heaven and Hell that so upset our MYFers. Like I said, I left town shortly after that, and I don't know if the other people were as affected by it as I was. I don't remember voting on the board of directors at Elsdon, but I do remember voting on a couple other issues. One was to buy the house next door for a parsonage, and the other was to demolish the church building and construct a new one on the site. I voted "yes" on both of them, but I don't remember if I ever was inside either the parsonage or the new church. I think I became eligible to vote when I went through the confirmation procedure.
Some parts of the Bible are more interesting than others. I always preferred the story telling parts to the rants of the prophets and the poetry of King Solomon, but that's just me. One thing you need to keep in mind is that the stories are not always in chronological order. Genesis and Exodus start out that way, but the story line is interrupted by Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, which generally repeats the Exodus story, but with more detail than most people want to know. Joshua picks up where Exodus left off, and then you get into some more stories that are not all in sequential order. Solomon's stuff is right in the middle, then comes the prophets. The New Testament starts out by telling the story of Jesus four times by four different authors, each having a slightly different perspective. The Acts of the Apostles tells about what happened after Jesus left the scene. Then you get into some letters, mostly by Paul, and then its winds up with Revelation, which reads like a surrealistic nightmare. There is another part, called The Apocrypha, which only the Catholics have. I have never read it directly, but I have a book that summarizes it quite well. It's about how the Jews overthrew their Greek overlords and restored the Kingdom of Israel for about one generation, whereupon it fell apart due to internal squabbling like it had done the first time, making it vulnerable to the Roman conquest.
You asked about the "Reconstruction", but I think you meant to say "Resurrection". Like I said before, Jesus and Paul talked about it, but they never explained the whole concept as one would when teaching it to someone who has never heard of it before. I think Revelation was supposed to do that but, you know.....
I don't think that people just make up religions because they have nothing else to do. I was going to say that religions don't just fall from the sky but, many of them claim to have done just that. Some of them likely evolved over time, but many of them have a founding father who may or may not have been a real historical person. Hinduism seems to have been formed by numerous religions assimilating each other, and Christianity itself has done some of that. If, by "morality". you mean intuitive altruism and are excluding all the specific rules and regulations, I tend to agree that probably came first. I am not done with those Canaanites yet, there is more I want to know about them, and will look into it when I get some time.
Yes, it was the trashing of our cherished misconceptions about Heaven and Hell that so upset our MYFers. Like I said, I left town shortly after that, and I don't know if the other people were as affected by it as I was. I don't remember voting on the board of directors at Elsdon, but I do remember voting on a couple other issues. One was to buy the house next door for a parsonage, and the other was to demolish the church building and construct a new one on the site. I voted "yes" on both of them, but I don't remember if I ever was inside either the parsonage or the new church. I think I became eligible to vote when I went through the confirmation procedure.
The Tale of Sally O'Maye
Those bible stories are all a mishmash me to me. Before talking to you I
had no idea what order they came in. Maybe the one I remember best is
where somebody gets tossed into a furnace, and actually that's all I
remember about it. But we had a furnace in our basement and I had
watched my dad shovel coal into it and the thought of being tossed in
there was pretty scary.
I don't think religions come from anywhere in particular. I think it's just in our makeup to make up religions, like we do languages. Isolate a group of people and they will soon come up with their own language and their own religion. I think wiki says that the Canaanites who became Israelites were sort of like the hillbillies or downtrodden of Canaan, and maybe the Baal worshipers didn't want them in their church lest they overrun it and take it over, so they had to make up their own.
I remember Hammurabi, probably from like 5th grade or something. It was a big deal to have all the laws written down like that, though I imagine they all had a rider something like, unless the king wants to do something different. Still it was a big event, probably the first lawyers appeared on the earth then, and we all know how lawyers have enriched the world ever since.
I don't know how that went with Canaan and the Egyptians, but I'm pretty sure that this land changed hands many times. Sometimes the Egyptians were the big enchiladas and sometimes the guys from the north were and sometimes both of them were involved in internal upheavals and the Canaanites/Israelis were left alone.
Those guys in the second or fourth or whatever it was century, picked and chose the books of the bible. Certainly we of this modern age could make a better selection. Did those New Testament guys have some details on the Reconstruction? Nobody says you go straight to Heaven? Well I guess it makes sense. If dear Aunt Rosie went to Heaven twenty years ago, she would already have plenty of friends up there and probably wouldn't have much time for her annoying nephew.
Did we ever elect a board of directors at Elsdon? I don't remember that, but I guess I would have been too young to vote, and my parents, though officially members, gave the place a wide berth because it always seemed to be asking for money.
Morality comes way before religion. Morality is in our genes probably since we became mammals, and it was certainly intensified when we became the most social of animals. I refer to altruism here and none of the shalt nots of the bibles or all the shalt nots added on as religion became more official.
I suppose you would know more than I about it, but I don't think deists ever had churches. I think they had believing that God doesn't get involved a lot in common, but as to what they thought God wanted I reckon they all had their own ideas.
You know there are some atheists, I think they call themselves some kind of humanists, who don't believe in god, but miss all that churchy stuff, so they have some kind of halls where they dress up and go and sing and stuff I imagine, which to me is crazy man crazy. I'm with you Beagles one of the best things about not believing in God, or not believing in Him very much, is that you don't have to go to church anymore.
Didn't like my story about the butcher's son and the confused preacher and little Salome (Sally) hiking up her skirts whenever she sat down in the pew? Damn I thought i had a bestseller and a major motion picture there. Just to get things correct. The idea that blew the doors of the MYF was that you don't get to heaven right away? Still doesn't seem all that shocking, and I still wonder about the sheep never getting to overrun heaven.
I don't think religions come from anywhere in particular. I think it's just in our makeup to make up religions, like we do languages. Isolate a group of people and they will soon come up with their own language and their own religion. I think wiki says that the Canaanites who became Israelites were sort of like the hillbillies or downtrodden of Canaan, and maybe the Baal worshipers didn't want them in their church lest they overrun it and take it over, so they had to make up their own.
I remember Hammurabi, probably from like 5th grade or something. It was a big deal to have all the laws written down like that, though I imagine they all had a rider something like, unless the king wants to do something different. Still it was a big event, probably the first lawyers appeared on the earth then, and we all know how lawyers have enriched the world ever since.
I don't know how that went with Canaan and the Egyptians, but I'm pretty sure that this land changed hands many times. Sometimes the Egyptians were the big enchiladas and sometimes the guys from the north were and sometimes both of them were involved in internal upheavals and the Canaanites/Israelis were left alone.
Those guys in the second or fourth or whatever it was century, picked and chose the books of the bible. Certainly we of this modern age could make a better selection. Did those New Testament guys have some details on the Reconstruction? Nobody says you go straight to Heaven? Well I guess it makes sense. If dear Aunt Rosie went to Heaven twenty years ago, she would already have plenty of friends up there and probably wouldn't have much time for her annoying nephew.
Did we ever elect a board of directors at Elsdon? I don't remember that, but I guess I would have been too young to vote, and my parents, though officially members, gave the place a wide berth because it always seemed to be asking for money.
Morality comes way before religion. Morality is in our genes probably since we became mammals, and it was certainly intensified when we became the most social of animals. I refer to altruism here and none of the shalt nots of the bibles or all the shalt nots added on as religion became more official.
I suppose you would know more than I about it, but I don't think deists ever had churches. I think they had believing that God doesn't get involved a lot in common, but as to what they thought God wanted I reckon they all had their own ideas.
You know there are some atheists, I think they call themselves some kind of humanists, who don't believe in god, but miss all that churchy stuff, so they have some kind of halls where they dress up and go and sing and stuff I imagine, which to me is crazy man crazy. I'm with you Beagles one of the best things about not believing in God, or not believing in Him very much, is that you don't have to go to church anymore.
Didn't like my story about the butcher's son and the confused preacher and little Salome (Sally) hiking up her skirts whenever she sat down in the pew? Damn I thought i had a bestseller and a major motion picture there. Just to get things correct. The idea that blew the doors of the MYF was that you don't get to heaven right away? Still doesn't seem all that shocking, and I still wonder about the sheep never getting to overrun heaven.
Tuesday, November 3, 2015
"Let My People Go!"
It has been hard for me to let go of the Exodus story, even though I already knew it was mostly apocryphal. As Wiki says, it is one of the most beloved stories in the Judeo-Christian tradition. My favorite part is when Moses stands up before the pharaoh and fearlessly demands that he "Let my people go!". I'm surprised that you, who were so disdainful of authority in your younger days, didn't identify with that.
Okay, so the Israelites were just regular Canaanites who "got religion". From whence did they get it? Religions don't just drop out of the sky you know. Most religions start with a prophet who has some kind of transcendental experience and can't wait to tell all his friends about it. Most people consider Abraham to be the founder of Judaism, except the Muslims who consider him to be the founder of Islam. Truth be known, Abraham wasn't much of a role model, and neither was Isaac or Jacob. They all did some goofy things that would be frowned upon in today's culture. Moses, however, was the law giver. Okay, so he probably got the idea from Hammurabi, but few people today remember Hammurabi, while everybody knows about Moses. I'm going to miss him.
I still want to know where Egypt fits in with all this. Wiki says that the Egyptians conquered Canaan before the Israelites did. Did the Israelites kick the Egyptians out, or did they just move in to fill the power vacuum after the Egyptians left for some other reason?
I don't think you can kick books out of the Bible. By some accounts, there were books that should have been included and weren't, but that's not exactly the same thing. The Bible doesn't say anything about itself because it is a collection of books by different authors. Most Bibles have some kind of introduction printed in them, but the introduction isn't really part of the original Bible. Be that as it may, if you just blow off the book of Revelation, you still have to deal with everything that Peter, Paul, and Jesus said about the Resurrection. If you want to go to Heaven immediately after you die, join the Persian followers of Zarathustra. They are still around, you know, have their own website and everything. Trouble is, with them, you still have to be resurrected after mankind has purged all the evil from the Earth, although you will likely have to wait longer for that to happen than you will have to wait for Jesus to come back and do it for us.
Like I said, most Protestant and Jewish congregations have some kind of board of directors that is elected by the members. When they need to fill a vacancy, they advertise in some magazine that all the preachers who are looking for work read. Then they interview the applicants and pick their favorite, but I think their choice of candidates still has to be approved by a vote of the general membership.
Morality and religion, religion and morality, potato, potahto. It's all formulated by people who are trying to make their lives better. The original Deists in the 18th Century wouldn't have been concerned with environmental issues because those hadn't been invented yet. In those days, people were still trying subdue Mother Nature and put her to work for the benefit of mankind. I don't know if there are any Deists still around today, and I don't want to find out. Practicing an extinct religion all by yourself has certain benefits: You don't have to go to church or Sunday school, you don't have to sing in the choir, you don't have to go to rummage sales and spaghetti suppers and, best of all, you don't have to give them your money.
Okay, so the Israelites were just regular Canaanites who "got religion". From whence did they get it? Religions don't just drop out of the sky you know. Most religions start with a prophet who has some kind of transcendental experience and can't wait to tell all his friends about it. Most people consider Abraham to be the founder of Judaism, except the Muslims who consider him to be the founder of Islam. Truth be known, Abraham wasn't much of a role model, and neither was Isaac or Jacob. They all did some goofy things that would be frowned upon in today's culture. Moses, however, was the law giver. Okay, so he probably got the idea from Hammurabi, but few people today remember Hammurabi, while everybody knows about Moses. I'm going to miss him.
I still want to know where Egypt fits in with all this. Wiki says that the Egyptians conquered Canaan before the Israelites did. Did the Israelites kick the Egyptians out, or did they just move in to fill the power vacuum after the Egyptians left for some other reason?
I don't think you can kick books out of the Bible. By some accounts, there were books that should have been included and weren't, but that's not exactly the same thing. The Bible doesn't say anything about itself because it is a collection of books by different authors. Most Bibles have some kind of introduction printed in them, but the introduction isn't really part of the original Bible. Be that as it may, if you just blow off the book of Revelation, you still have to deal with everything that Peter, Paul, and Jesus said about the Resurrection. If you want to go to Heaven immediately after you die, join the Persian followers of Zarathustra. They are still around, you know, have their own website and everything. Trouble is, with them, you still have to be resurrected after mankind has purged all the evil from the Earth, although you will likely have to wait longer for that to happen than you will have to wait for Jesus to come back and do it for us.
Like I said, most Protestant and Jewish congregations have some kind of board of directors that is elected by the members. When they need to fill a vacancy, they advertise in some magazine that all the preachers who are looking for work read. Then they interview the applicants and pick their favorite, but I think their choice of candidates still has to be approved by a vote of the general membership.
Morality and religion, religion and morality, potato, potahto. It's all formulated by people who are trying to make their lives better. The original Deists in the 18th Century wouldn't have been concerned with environmental issues because those hadn't been invented yet. In those days, people were still trying subdue Mother Nature and put her to work for the benefit of mankind. I don't know if there are any Deists still around today, and I don't want to find out. Practicing an extinct religion all by yourself has certain benefits: You don't have to go to church or Sunday school, you don't have to sing in the choir, you don't have to go to rummage sales and spaghetti suppers and, best of all, you don't have to give them your money.
The Night of the MYF Bombshell/The Novel/The Movie
As far as that resurrection thing how about the Occamesque solution of
tossing out the book of Revelations? It just barely got into the bible
about 1600 years ago by a bunch of guys who knew less about their
history than we do now. I don't think it says anywhere in the bible
that you can't throw books out of the bible. Now that I think about it
does the bible ever reference itself?
That would make a nice short story, the bomb dropped at the MYF meeting, young idealistic mouths opened wide with shock, and the young preacher suddenly not so sure that he is sure of what he is talking about and heading back to the halls of academe, and the butcher's son heading to the northwoods to have a place to do some deep thinking. Okay that last part is patently false, but I want a little poetic license here.
It, the bomb dropping, could come at the beginning or the end of the novel, I've decided it should be a novel. I like it in flashback with the preacher now preaching in some big fancy downtown church and the butcher's son in some cabin deep in the woods, and narrating inbetween would be the beautiful girl who the butcher's son was set to marry before he took off in the middle of the night without a word to anyone, and who had a little hanky panky, or maybe just thought of having some hanky panky, with the preacher. I'm thinking they will want to make a movie out of this best selling novel, and we're going to need a little sex interest and some bombshell starlet to make a splash at the theaters. Hmmm. I wonder if we can add in the story of Salome and John. Maybe Salome was a little MYF hottie who the butcher's son had succumbed to in a misguided moment of passion, and maybe the preacher had chided her for wearing her skirts too short and she had run to her uncle who was some bigwig in the congregation.
But I digress I suppose. So the rev's bombshell was that Revelation resurrection thing? Doesn't seem all that shocking to me, The bad still get punished and the good still get rewarded, just a little more complicated path is all. Though it still sticks in my craw about those snooty Elects living by themselves in heaven. Were they afraid that if they let the sheep in there that the sheep would soon be taking it over?
I think Occam would be happier with the explanation that the Israelites were just Canaanites who got religion rather than that they were guys who went to Egypt and back and maybe hightailed it across the Red Sea ahead of Pharaoh's chariots and the whole thing somehow involved the poorly understood late bronze age breakdown.
I only remember once that those trays of grape juice and torn up bread came out. I'm sure it never happened in the early days when I was racking up my five years of perfect attendance. Of course my attendance was spotty after about the age of twelve, and a couple years later I lost my faith but I was too young to run off to the northwoods, and surely not cool enough to lose myself in the charms of some vengeful MYF hottie.
How does the congregation know who to pick for their next preacher? Well I guess there are schools churning out new ones every June, and I reckon they sign up for so many years so that when their contract is up they toss their hats in the ring.
You know I think morality preceded religion. There are some fine distinctions in Deism that I don't quite understand. I do understand that you are pretty sure that God, I think you still call Him God, wants you to conserve the land. But I guess another deist could be equally sure that God wanted for the land to be covered with interstates and Wal Marts.
That would make a nice short story, the bomb dropped at the MYF meeting, young idealistic mouths opened wide with shock, and the young preacher suddenly not so sure that he is sure of what he is talking about and heading back to the halls of academe, and the butcher's son heading to the northwoods to have a place to do some deep thinking. Okay that last part is patently false, but I want a little poetic license here.
It, the bomb dropping, could come at the beginning or the end of the novel, I've decided it should be a novel. I like it in flashback with the preacher now preaching in some big fancy downtown church and the butcher's son in some cabin deep in the woods, and narrating inbetween would be the beautiful girl who the butcher's son was set to marry before he took off in the middle of the night without a word to anyone, and who had a little hanky panky, or maybe just thought of having some hanky panky, with the preacher. I'm thinking they will want to make a movie out of this best selling novel, and we're going to need a little sex interest and some bombshell starlet to make a splash at the theaters. Hmmm. I wonder if we can add in the story of Salome and John. Maybe Salome was a little MYF hottie who the butcher's son had succumbed to in a misguided moment of passion, and maybe the preacher had chided her for wearing her skirts too short and she had run to her uncle who was some bigwig in the congregation.
But I digress I suppose. So the rev's bombshell was that Revelation resurrection thing? Doesn't seem all that shocking to me, The bad still get punished and the good still get rewarded, just a little more complicated path is all. Though it still sticks in my craw about those snooty Elects living by themselves in heaven. Were they afraid that if they let the sheep in there that the sheep would soon be taking it over?
I think Occam would be happier with the explanation that the Israelites were just Canaanites who got religion rather than that they were guys who went to Egypt and back and maybe hightailed it across the Red Sea ahead of Pharaoh's chariots and the whole thing somehow involved the poorly understood late bronze age breakdown.
I only remember once that those trays of grape juice and torn up bread came out. I'm sure it never happened in the early days when I was racking up my five years of perfect attendance. Of course my attendance was spotty after about the age of twelve, and a couple years later I lost my faith but I was too young to run off to the northwoods, and surely not cool enough to lose myself in the charms of some vengeful MYF hottie.
How does the congregation know who to pick for their next preacher? Well I guess there are schools churning out new ones every June, and I reckon they sign up for so many years so that when their contract is up they toss their hats in the ring.
You know I think morality preceded religion. There are some fine distinctions in Deism that I don't quite understand. I do understand that you are pretty sure that God, I think you still call Him God, wants you to conserve the land. But I guess another deist could be equally sure that God wanted for the land to be covered with interstates and Wal Marts.
Monday, November 2, 2015
Holy Moses!
I think that most of the people at Elsdon believed something like the "common culture" version of the afterlife, until Rev. Anderson came along and told us what the Bible has to say about it. It was not long after he dropped that bomb at an M.Y.F. meeting that he left and went back to school, and it wasn't long after that I split for Alaska. My first impression was that the good reverend had made some kind of mistake, and it took a few years of reading and thinking about it for me to come around to his way of thinking. Somewhere along the way, I came across that statement Jesus made about the Apocalypse coming in one generation, which confused me even more. I guess Occam's razor caught up with me eventually, although I didn't know that's what it was called. Isn't that the one that says the obvious explanation is the most likely explanation? Anyway, the most obvious explanation, but the one that few Christians are willing to consider, is that the prediction of the impending Apocalypse was just plain wrong. Either Jesus was mistaken, or the Bible does not accurately reflect what Jesus said.
The reason Salome was pissed at John the Baptist was that he went around telling people that she was a shameless hussy, or words to that effect. Salome was King Herod's daughter or niece or something, and one day she danced so pretty for Herod that he offered to give her anything she wanted, which turned out to John's head on a platter. I have heard of the Essenes, maybe that's the cult I was thinking about.
According to the Bible, the Israelites were not carried off to Egypt like their descendants were carried off to Babylon centuries later. They came wandering in out of the desert during a time of famine and were allowed to camp in the suburb of Goshen. There they became fruitful and multiplied to the point that the Egyptians were beginning to worry about them taking over the neighborhood. You can find the whole story in the Wiki article that we recently read about the Israelites. At some point during the Israelites stay there they, and everybody else in Egypt, became the slaves of the pharaoh because there was another famine and the pharaoh was the only one who had any food. When the citizens had nothing left to trade for food, they sold themselves.
I am willing to accept the possibility that the whole Exodus story is bogus, but that leaves us with the question of how the Israelites managed to take over Canaan at a time when Egypt allegedly had dominion over the whole region. As somebody said on Wiki, if the Exodus story was true, the Israelites would have been fleeing from Egypt to Egypt. I think the Bronze Age Collapse theory plugs in nicely here. One thing for sure, the Israelites did in fact take over Canaan. I don't think anyone disputes that.
Rev. Schact certainly did not introduce communion to the Elsdon congregation, although I seem to remember that she increased the frequency from quarterly to monthly. The Catholics do it at every mass, but the Protestants generally do it less often. The Methodists always used grape juice instead of wine because Methodists are not supposed to drink alcohol. I don't remember any wafers at Elsdon, we used little squares of bread. The Catholics use a wafer that they call "The Host", which is supposed to contain both bread and wine, and is magically transformed into the actual body and blood of Christ when it touches your tongue (transubstantiation). Protestants generally believe that the bread and wine only symbolizes the body and blood, although some of them believe that it is, for all practical purposes, the same thing (consubstantiation). Wars have been fought over this. One of the principal issues of the Hussite war in Bohemia was whether or not to use both bread and wine (communion in two kinds), or just the wafer (communion in one kind).
Methodist ministers are not assigned to a church. The congregation has a board of directors that hires them and can fire them. I think most Protestant denominations and Jewish congregations do it like that.
Religion and morality seem to have evolved together, kind of a chicken and egg thing, and it is only in the last few hundred years that anybody has tried to separate the two. As a Deist, I believe that religion in a human activity, so morality would come from people, not from God. In a manner of speaking, though, all things come from God because He is the creator of us all.
The reason Salome was pissed at John the Baptist was that he went around telling people that she was a shameless hussy, or words to that effect. Salome was King Herod's daughter or niece or something, and one day she danced so pretty for Herod that he offered to give her anything she wanted, which turned out to John's head on a platter. I have heard of the Essenes, maybe that's the cult I was thinking about.
According to the Bible, the Israelites were not carried off to Egypt like their descendants were carried off to Babylon centuries later. They came wandering in out of the desert during a time of famine and were allowed to camp in the suburb of Goshen. There they became fruitful and multiplied to the point that the Egyptians were beginning to worry about them taking over the neighborhood. You can find the whole story in the Wiki article that we recently read about the Israelites. At some point during the Israelites stay there they, and everybody else in Egypt, became the slaves of the pharaoh because there was another famine and the pharaoh was the only one who had any food. When the citizens had nothing left to trade for food, they sold themselves.
I am willing to accept the possibility that the whole Exodus story is bogus, but that leaves us with the question of how the Israelites managed to take over Canaan at a time when Egypt allegedly had dominion over the whole region. As somebody said on Wiki, if the Exodus story was true, the Israelites would have been fleeing from Egypt to Egypt. I think the Bronze Age Collapse theory plugs in nicely here. One thing for sure, the Israelites did in fact take over Canaan. I don't think anyone disputes that.
Rev. Schact certainly did not introduce communion to the Elsdon congregation, although I seem to remember that she increased the frequency from quarterly to monthly. The Catholics do it at every mass, but the Protestants generally do it less often. The Methodists always used grape juice instead of wine because Methodists are not supposed to drink alcohol. I don't remember any wafers at Elsdon, we used little squares of bread. The Catholics use a wafer that they call "The Host", which is supposed to contain both bread and wine, and is magically transformed into the actual body and blood of Christ when it touches your tongue (transubstantiation). Protestants generally believe that the bread and wine only symbolizes the body and blood, although some of them believe that it is, for all practical purposes, the same thing (consubstantiation). Wars have been fought over this. One of the principal issues of the Hussite war in Bohemia was whether or not to use both bread and wine (communion in two kinds), or just the wafer (communion in one kind).
Methodist ministers are not assigned to a church. The congregation has a board of directors that hires them and can fire them. I think most Protestant denominations and Jewish congregations do it like that.
Religion and morality seem to have evolved together, kind of a chicken and egg thing, and it is only in the last few hundred years that anybody has tried to separate the two. As a Deist, I believe that religion in a human activity, so morality would come from people, not from God. In a manner of speaking, though, all things come from God because He is the creator of us all.
shave your face and your mind with Occam's razor
That's good, that I didn't have to read the bible. i did pull it over
to my lazy boy and opened it up and tried to read a little bit, but it
was awfully slow going, there was no rush to get to any point.
What were we taught at Elsdon about the afterlife? The impression I left with was that as long as you didn't do anything awfully terrible once you died you would almost immediately go to heaven where one of the big moments would be meeting up with those who went before you, and after that it was pretty vague though probably churchy. Of course I didn't pay a lot of attention to what was being said, so maybe that is all stuff that I picked up from the common culture.
I'm sure you know that in Jesus's time there were all sorts of sects and cults in the land and some of them I think had some idea of immortality. John sounds like an essene doesn't he, hanging in the desert and eating locusts and honey? Isn't he the guy who got his head chopped off and put on a platter for Salome, was it? Odd thing for a young hottie to want, but they didn't have Cadillacs back in that day.
I didn't say there weren't some Israelis in Egypt. I just said they weren't all taken there en masse and then broke out en masse later.
This is the first I've heard of the late bronze age collapse. It was all over wiki but the consensus seemed to be that there was no consensus as to what caused it. I suppose if you want to fabricate an explanation for something that probably never happened one theory is as good as another. But haven't you ever heard of Occam's razor?
I don't know why none of those big shaving houses has never come up with a razor named Occam's. Not only is your face smooth of fuzz, but your mind is cleared of all those fuzzy thoughts also. Babes go for a guy with a smooth face and an uncluttered mind.
Overrun by Mexicans, is that like them taking over? I don't see many states with Mexican governors or senators or anything. And you do realize that one of the big reasons that those guys were holed up in the Alamo was that Mexico did not permit slavery and those guys wanted to keep their slaves. And one of the results of that war and of the Mexican American wars was that lots of Mexicans entered the country. They didn't go anywhere, we moved the borders.
Maybe that rev Schact was kind of high churchy, i seem to remember that she also introduced communion (grape juice communion, I'm not sure about the wafers) to the church, which caused considerable muttering among the brethren who thought this was awfully close to dressing up like the whore of Babylon. I wonder what it was like being assigned to Elsdon Methodist. I can't imagine it was a step up. There were some Lutherans by 60th and Spaulding, but I can't think of any other protestant churches in our neighborhood.
Saturday nights I watch a DVD and once it's over I smoke some dope and watch it again. It's always much better the second time around. I am not sure if it's because I am noticing details that went by me the first time or if it's just because of the dope.
Along with watching the movie I get all these dope insights which I feel a need to write down right then and there because they are very insightful and important. The next morning when I am clearing away the beer cans there is my list, and in the light of the morning those issues are not as important as they were when I wrote them down.
Here's one from Saturday night. Why is God's morality necessarily better than ours? This is something I've long wondered. God does all these terrible things in the bible, and it's just kind of shrugged off as God being God, or that goofy excuse that we cannot know the will of God. Well if we cannot know His will how do we know that we are pleasing Him when we give to the poor or refrain from fish on Friday? Sure He's all powerful, but what does that have to do with Him being good. Hitler, Stalin, and Mao, they were all pretty powerful and nobody anymore thinks they were good.
So I don't know, how about that?
What were we taught at Elsdon about the afterlife? The impression I left with was that as long as you didn't do anything awfully terrible once you died you would almost immediately go to heaven where one of the big moments would be meeting up with those who went before you, and after that it was pretty vague though probably churchy. Of course I didn't pay a lot of attention to what was being said, so maybe that is all stuff that I picked up from the common culture.
I'm sure you know that in Jesus's time there were all sorts of sects and cults in the land and some of them I think had some idea of immortality. John sounds like an essene doesn't he, hanging in the desert and eating locusts and honey? Isn't he the guy who got his head chopped off and put on a platter for Salome, was it? Odd thing for a young hottie to want, but they didn't have Cadillacs back in that day.
I didn't say there weren't some Israelis in Egypt. I just said they weren't all taken there en masse and then broke out en masse later.
This is the first I've heard of the late bronze age collapse. It was all over wiki but the consensus seemed to be that there was no consensus as to what caused it. I suppose if you want to fabricate an explanation for something that probably never happened one theory is as good as another. But haven't you ever heard of Occam's razor?
I don't know why none of those big shaving houses has never come up with a razor named Occam's. Not only is your face smooth of fuzz, but your mind is cleared of all those fuzzy thoughts also. Babes go for a guy with a smooth face and an uncluttered mind.
Overrun by Mexicans, is that like them taking over? I don't see many states with Mexican governors or senators or anything. And you do realize that one of the big reasons that those guys were holed up in the Alamo was that Mexico did not permit slavery and those guys wanted to keep their slaves. And one of the results of that war and of the Mexican American wars was that lots of Mexicans entered the country. They didn't go anywhere, we moved the borders.
Maybe that rev Schact was kind of high churchy, i seem to remember that she also introduced communion (grape juice communion, I'm not sure about the wafers) to the church, which caused considerable muttering among the brethren who thought this was awfully close to dressing up like the whore of Babylon. I wonder what it was like being assigned to Elsdon Methodist. I can't imagine it was a step up. There were some Lutherans by 60th and Spaulding, but I can't think of any other protestant churches in our neighborhood.
Saturday nights I watch a DVD and once it's over I smoke some dope and watch it again. It's always much better the second time around. I am not sure if it's because I am noticing details that went by me the first time or if it's just because of the dope.
Along with watching the movie I get all these dope insights which I feel a need to write down right then and there because they are very insightful and important. The next morning when I am clearing away the beer cans there is my list, and in the light of the morning those issues are not as important as they were when I wrote them down.
Here's one from Saturday night. Why is God's morality necessarily better than ours? This is something I've long wondered. God does all these terrible things in the bible, and it's just kind of shrugged off as God being God, or that goofy excuse that we cannot know the will of God. Well if we cannot know His will how do we know that we are pleasing Him when we give to the poor or refrain from fish on Friday? Sure He's all powerful, but what does that have to do with Him being good. Hitler, Stalin, and Mao, they were all pretty powerful and nobody anymore thinks they were good.
So I don't know, how about that?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)